The Last
Bel Canto Opera, La Traviata
“The Lost One” and “The Wayward Woman”
are translations often given the title of La Traviata in
various English editions. However, I have often thought of the opera
as The Last One — the last Italian Bel Canto opera, the end
of the great era of deliriously florid song as devised by Rossini,
Bellini and Donizetti.
The
style of opera writing changed radically after La Traviata.
With the emergence of Richard Wagner and the German school of singing
and the more dramatic style of the Italian Verismo school, opera
largely abandoned the vocal style and technique that had dominated
the European stage for more than 150 years.
Giuseppe Verdi had admirably tried in all of his previous operas
to achieve a maturity of composition within the framework of the
Donizetti style. He achieved varying degrees of success with such
works as I Masnadieri, I Due Foscari, I Lombardi, Giovanna D’Arco,
Ernani. They bore the hallmarks of great Bel Canto operas —
thrilling overtures, magnificent arias, soaring duets and ensembles,
and finales with dramatic concertato sections. Wonderful works,
yes, but not quite as perfect as Rossini’s Semiramide,
Bellini’s Norma or Donizetti’s Lucrezia
Borgia. Not until Verdi completed Il Trovatore and
La Traviata, that is.
Verdi actually worked on Il Trovatore and La Traviata
at the same time, and both premiered in the same year, 1853.
La Traviata was a great disaster when it opened at La Fenice
in Venice. Legend blamed it on the great girth of the prima donna,
who could not convince the Venetian audience that Violetta was dying
of consumption. Verdi laid the blame squarely on the poor performances
of the principals. Thereafter, however, the the opera was an immediate
and lasting success wherever it played, and it has remained a perennial
favorite of the international repertoire.
In style of composition, La Traviata can be described
only as the quintessential Bel Canto opera. From Prelude to Recitative,
from Aria to Cabaletta, from Duet to Ensemble, and from Chorus to
Concertato, it is the perfect “old school” opera.
Verdi never composed in this style again. Nor did any other major
composer. He never looked back. All of his operas to come, from
Aida through Falstaff reflect a new day of singing
in opera.
So let us return, as Verdi surely must have, for one last visit
to a world of soaring melodies, dazzling cadenzas, of romance and
melodrama, of bravura and bravado.
Let’s look back on Bel Canto — one last time!
Synopsis
Act I
A salon in the home of Violetta Valéry
A cheerful party is taking place at the home of Violetta Valéry,
a beautiful Parisian demimondaine. Viscount Gastone de Letorières
arrives and presents his friend, Alfredo Germont. He tells Violetta
that Alfredo has long been a secret admirer and had even called
daily during her recent illness to inquire about her. Baron Douphol,
another admirer of Violetta, is angered by the conversation and
refuses to propose a toast when invited by the Viscount.
Alfredo accepts the invitation and sings an impassioned drinking
song to beauty and love. Later, as the others depart for the ballroom
to dance, Violetta is overcome by a fainting spell. Alfredo stays
behind to assist her. He then confesses he has been in love with
her for more than a year. Violetta does not reciprocate but offers
friendship. She gives him a flower from her bosom and bids him return
when it has withered. Alfredo, joyously accepting the suggestion,
tells her goodnight.
After her guests have gone, Violetta ponders Alfredo’s proffered
love. After some champagne she returns to her true character and
declares she will remain forever uncommitted—free to pass
from pleasure to pleasure.
Act II, Scene I
Violetta’s country house outside Paris.
Violetta is living with Alfredo in the country, having abandoned
her life of ease and luxury in town. Annina, Violetta’s maid
and confidante, enters and tells Alfredo she has been sent to take
away all Violetta’s things, which must be sold to pay her
debts. Alfredo realizes the sacrifices that Violetta has made to
live with him; he leaves for Paris, determined not to be shamed
by his mistress’ sacrifice.
Violetta enters. She receives an unexpected visitor, Giorgio Germont,
Alfredo’s father. He declares that Alfredo is ruining himself
to keep her as his mistress. When Germont comments on the luxury
of the country retreat, Violetta shows him the papers that have
been prepared for the sale of all her possessions. He asks her to
give up Alfredo, explaining that by continuing the liaison, Alfredo
is prejudicing the impending marriage of his younger sister. Giorgio
Germont’s insistence convinces Violetta, who agrees to save
Alfredo’s sister by leaving him forever. She is preparing
a letter as Alfredo returns. His father has gone out into the garden.
Alfredo, not realizing his father has already arrived, explains
to Violetta that the elder Germont has written him a severe letter,
but he assures her that his father will approve of her as soon as
he meets her. Violetta pretends that she must leave so as not to
be present when father meets son, but a messenger returns with her
letter of farewell. Alfredo is stricken with grief at the loss of
Violetta and when his father tries to persuade him to return to
his family, Alfredo refuses. Finding on a table an invitation that
Flora Bervoix has sent Violetta, he resolves to go to Flora’s
in hope of finding Violetta.
Act II, Scene II
The salon of Flora Bervoix
Alfredo arrives at Flora’s brilliantly lighted salon just
as the guests are beginning to gamble. Then Violetta arrives, escorted
by Baron Douphol. Alfredo is incredibly lucky at cards, explaining
that he who is unlucky in love is lucky at cards. The Baron, incensed
at Alfredo’s insolence, challenges him to play. Alfredo accepts
and beats the Baron repeatedly at high stakes.
When all the others retire to dinner, Violetta remains behind to
entreat Alfredo to leave lest the Baron challenge him to a duel.
Alfredo answers that he will leave only if she accompanies him.
Unwilling to reveal that she must break with him because of his
father, Violetta declares that she is in love with the Baron.
Alfredo, in a frenzy of jealousy, calls all the guests into the
room and announces that he had not known that she had made great
financial sacrifices to live with him. In a rage, he throws a purse
at her feet and calls upon all to witness that he has paid her in
full. The elder Germont has entered just in time to witness Alfredo’s
caddish bravado and joins the others in reviling him for his unchivalrous
conduct. Alfredo, realizing the lengths to which his jealousy has
carried him, is contrite, but realizes he is helpless to make amends.
The Baron assures Alfredo that he must answer for the insult on
the field of honor.
Act III
Violetta’s bedroom
Violetta’s illness has brought her to the point of death.
Her physician, Doctor Grenvil, examines her and tells Annina that
Violetta has but a few hours to live. Violetta reads a letter from
Giorgio Germont, in which she learns that Alfredo has gone abroad
after wounding the Baron in a duel. He knows now of the great sacrifice
Violetta has made and is returning to beg her forgiveness. Alfredo
returns and the two lovers are reunited at last. But it is too late.
Violetta tries to rise from her bed, but cannot. The elder Germont
calls to ask her pardon. Violetta, comforted by the presence of
the man she has so tragically loved, rises for a moment from her
bed, then collapses in a faint. A moment later, she is dead.
|