The SL Record Report 08-07 (Aug 2007) Current Editor: Allen Evenson Summer Salutations fellow Squad Leaders! This is the latest update through end of July 2007. (Includes 2007 WBC Results) Please, Please, _Please_ Check the records for any inaccuracies and notify me directly. The search continues for my replacement though I will strive to issue another update (at least) this year. If you are interested in taking over the role of ROS Meister - please email me at my address below. Submit _your_ reports via the web: http://www.alpage2.ukfsn.org/ or, email to me directly: asevenson@comcast.net Until Next Time, Allen E. --------------------------------------------------------------- THE CUMULATIVE REPORTED RECORD FOR THE SL DISCUSSION LIST --------------------------------------------------------------- This is the official record for the SL Discussion List. The format was originally conceived for ASL by John Foley, and is now automated for ASL at http://www.jrvdev.com/ROAR/VER1/default.asp This list for SL was started and maintained by Dan Leader until July 1994. It then passed into the capable hands of Kevin Pietersen until November 1995. Alain Chabot maintained it from December 1995 to December 2003. The *only* qualification for submitting records is that you subscribe to the SL Mailing list. YOU MAY SUBMIT RECORDS FOR NON-SUBSCRIBERS. YOU MAY SUBMIT RECORDS FROM PAST YEARS. _AND_ If you attend a tournament, you may submit the tournament's results. I mean all of them, not only your own games. Please keep that in mind if you travel to one of them over the Summer. To submit your record of scenarios played, please send the scenario ID#, and the scenario winner for each of the scenarios you have completed or can vouch having been played. When you send me mail, I'll promptly send you a thank you note to confirm my receipt of your mail. [ED Note: I have not been sending individual confirmations as of late.] Please send your record entries to asevenson@comcast.net or use the form at "http://www.alpage2.ukfsn.org/". Make it clear in the subject line that the message is meant to add to the record (or correct it, or whatever). I suggest the subject "For the record". In the body of your message, tell me the ID# (if one exists) and the Title of the scenario and which side won. If you played against a fellow list member, please let me know who that person is and/or his email address. The best would be for you to use the same format I use for the recent dispatches below. Thanks for your cooperation. As usual, I remind you to send me email entries with a subject field that clearly identifies your message has containing a record entry. I may have omitted entries in the past if it was not clear at all what the message was about. I receive a *LOT* of email every day, and I tend to delete quite a bit of stuff. Feel free to include comments, after action reports. I will gladly read them and may even respond. But make sure the record entry itself is up front. If the message includes many entries, make sure they are all together. Do not assume I will read on and on only to find another report buried at the bottom of the email. Please do NOT include scenarios played solitaire. Play against any opponent by any means (FTF, PBM, PBeM) is great. I will accept the records for all SL/COI/COD/GI scenarios that have been published by TAHGC, either in the modules, the supplemental scenarios, or in the GENERAL. Records of non-AH scenarios will also be accepted if they have been published somewhere; these will be attached to the end with details of their origin and where they may be purchased or copied from. Please tell me about any mistakes you find. Thank you for your help. If you want to join the SL ladder or report a ladder game in progress, please contact Alan Yngve at a-yngve@mindspring.com Recent Dispatches --------------------------------------------------------------- Here are the latest scenario results from the listees. These people are the reporters, not necessarily the scenario winners. If you see any mistakes in *your* summary, please write immediately. (Please note that when I get multiple reports of the same game, I list it under the first player to report). Recent dispatches are arranged in chronilogical order of receipt. The number to the right is the serial dispatch number) --------------------------------------------------------------- A special thanks is extended to the following people, since without them this database simply would not exist. Company of Contributors As of the September 2002 Record, those whose last contribution dates from 5 years or more are retired to a special section for the attritioned members. If you see yourself on the verge of consignment to the scrap heap (or you happen to have been tossed in it) and it bothers you, the time has come to dust off those dice and play and report a game. 01/08/07 Bill Thomson o3.1 Valley of Death Russian (P. Scott) 3600 01/13/07 Alan Yngve 104 The Penetration of Rostov German (C. Stewart) 3601 WG110 Recon in Force B German (R. Carignan) 3602 o60.1 The Workers Strike Back German (P. Grasha) 3603 7 Buccholz Station American (B. Ingram) 3604 8 Bitche Salient American (J. Olsen) 3605 15 Hube's Pocket German (B. Black) 3606 2006 SL Open Round 5 AY04 Aachen Redoubt 3 German, 6 American, 2 Draws 3607-3617 Summer in Russia Rnd 1,2 GTS1 Mirnaya Derevnya 1 German, 2 Russian, 2 Draws 3618-3622 2007 SL Open Round 1 AY04 Aachen Redoubt 4 German, 1 American 3623-3627 DE0 Back to the sea 1 German, 1 American 3628,3629 o34.4 France 1944 3 German, 3 American 3630-3635 2007 SL Open Round 2 AY04 Aachen Redoubt 2 German, 1 American 3636-3638 DE0 Back to the Sea 4 German, 1 American 3639-3643 o34.4 France 1944 1 German, 2 American 3644-3646 01/16/2007 Bill Thomson 10 Hitdorf on the Rhine American (C. Young) 3647 01/20/2007 Bill Thomson o6.1 Attempt to Relieve Korsun German (P. Pollard) 3648 01/20/2007 Bill Thomson WG208 Flugplatz 51 Russian (P. Pollard) 3649 01/20/2007 Pete Pollard WG208 Flugplatz 51 Russian (E. Filipkowski) 3650 01/21/2007 Bill Thomson W97 The Breaking Wave American (P. Pollard) 3651 01/24/2007 Bill Thomson T1 First Crises at AGN German (P. Scott) 3652 01/29/2007 Bill Thomson o18.7 Syrtzevo Russian (P. Grasha) 3653 02/01/2007 Brian Gagnon 2 The Tractor Works German (C. Bryer) 3654 02/05/2007 Bill Thomson WG102 Tooth and Nail German (A. Evenson) 3655 Prezcon 2007 Results 02/25/2007 Bill Thomson o60.1 Mogilev German 3656 2 The Tractor Works German 3657 T1 First Crisis of AGN German 3658 02/27/2007 Alan Yngve GA0 Through the Gauntlet Russian (R. Timek) 3659 03/13/2007 Steve Dell 4 The Hedgehog of Piepsk Russian (N. Ekengren) 3660 03/13/2007 Steve Dell BE0 Hasty Assault Russian (C. Dye) 3661 03/25/2007 Alan Yngve 8 The Bitche Salient American (B. Ingram) 3662 03/25/2007 Alan Yngve EP0 Tanker's Delight 2 American (O. Osterbrink) 3663,3664 03/25/2007 Alan Yngve GA0 Through the Gauntlet German (R. Timek) 3665 03/26/2007 Alan Yngve EP1 Tanker's Delight German (O. Osterbrink) 3666 04/11/2007 Brian Gagnon 4 The Hedgehog of Piepsk German (B. Easton) 3667 04/26/2007 Matthijs Zanden AL0 Forced March Russian (Michael) 3668 04/26/2007 Matthijs Zanden AL1 Forced March German (Michael) 3669 05/01/2007 Alan Yngve 16 Sowchos 79 German (B. Black) 3670 05/07/2007 Bill Thomson 21 Battle for the Warta Line German (s. Bramley) 3671 WBC 2007 Results 08/10/2007 Bill Thomson 7 Buchholz Station 1 German 3672 10 Hitdorf on the Rhine 1 American 3673 WG109 Recon in Force A 1 German, 1 American 3674,3675 WG110 Recon in Force B 3 German, 1 American 3676-3679 o35.1 Russia, 1941 3 German, 1 American 3680-3683 o36.1 Stalingrad, 20 Oct. 42 2 German, 2 American 3684-3687 WG102 Tooth a Nail 2 German 3688,3689 T1 First Crisis of AGN 1 Russian 3690 o3.1 Valley of Death 1 German 3691 33 A Belated Christmas 1 American 3692 John Baker [01-07] John Blazel [03-06] Bill Black [10-06] Mo Caraher [12-03] Dave Carter [12-02] Bob Capello [03-06] Alain Chabot [05-03] Gregory Clayton [01-05] Brian Collamer [06-03] Steve Dell [03-07] Joe Deuter [02-04] Charles Dye [07-04] Brent Easton [07-05] Chris Edwards [02-05] Gethyn Edwards [03-05] Neal Ekengren [11-06] Bob Eury [12-03] Stefan J. Eriksson [07-04] Allen Evenson [01-06] Eric Filipkowski [12-06] Marty Fix [05-04] Brian Gagnon [04-07] David Garvin [01-07] Richard Gregory [01-04] Bill Gormley [02-06] Thomas Gould [11-02] Philippe Grandclement [05-06] Gary Guyton [11-02] Andy Jackson [08-04] Timothy St. Jean [07-04] Dennis Jorgenson [12-04] Denny Koch [08-04] Paul Kuty [03-06] Greg Layton [08-06] Dan Leader [11-06] Mike Lembke [05-03] Brian Lucid [02-03] Neil Major [04-05] Mike Mac Ewan [12-03] Bob Menzel [01-06] Benjamin Meyer [09-05] Michael Moore [10-05] Andy Murby [10-03] Andrew Nick [04-06] Scott Oatley [06-04] John Olsen [04-06] Eric Pass [08-04] Pete Pollard [01-07] Scott Powers [02-06] Andreas Reuter [09-04] David Robert [06-06] Howard Rosenberg [04-04] Mike Ross [03-03] Jim Rupp [03-06] Jay Russ [02-03] Neil Ryan [09-04] Paul Scott [12-06] Juan Siso [12-05] David Stalnaker [07-05] Chris Stewart [02-06] Timothy StJean [05-05] Eric Storch [12-03] Curtis Teeters [07-06] Kevin Thatcher [10-03] Bill Thomson [08-07] Jeff Thorpe [12-02] Mike Toporowsky [02-06] Dan Tulloh [03-03] David VanBronkhorst [02-05] Roger Walker [05-01] Gunnar Wardenbach [11-04] Alistair Wilso [04-06] Jay White [12-02] Jay Yanek [08-06] Alan Yngve [05-07] Chuck Young [10-06] Matthijs Zanden [04-07] The following have contributed to this database in the (distant) past. They are not forgotten, but simply stacked neatly on a shelf: Roberto Antivalle * Jay Alexander * Colin Baker * John Barkoviak Peter Belford * Vic Cina * Tom Compter * Andrew Cowdery Jason Coyle * Cassady Craft * Matt Davis * Andy Dolphin Ted Ewen * John Fermendzin * Duncan Gibson * Peter Gustafson Michael Handiboe * Dan Hanna * Dave Hooton * David A. Howarth Ken Ives * Michael Kallner * Brandon Kassebaum * Jonathan Kenny Daniel J King * Jim Kiraly * David Krause * Andrew Kosoresow Tim Kuntz * Tom Lawnsby * Thomas Leete * Chuck Leonard Craig Limber * Maggie May * David Mercer * Paul Mills Linden Moore * Chuck Morford * André Nantel * Mike Noel John Pak * Kevin Pietersen * John Provan * Kenneth Ray Chris Roberson * Paul Rosengarth * Ken Rutkowski * Ken Rutsky Manuel Sanchez * Chris Sellers * Mark Sheppard * Christopher Short Darrel Sinclair * Lars Skagerlind * Neil Smark * Jack Standeven Chris Stevens * Tim Stevens * Eric Taylor * Joe Thomas Shaun Travers * Randolph Ubben * Neal Ulen * Pierre van Dyk Doug Williamson * Mike Wood * Geoffrey K. Bentz * K.J.Burger Tim DeLong * Eddy M.del Rio * Andy Dupras * Larry Koch Marc Lammers * Frédéric Olivo * Francis Spencer * Jack Wingard R. Butler * Lars Clausen * Ronin Kennedy * Brad Knoll Patrick Mc Gann * Ong Meng Soon * Fish Flowers * Jon Grantham RC Roark ************************************************************************ Summary Statistics ------------------------------------------------------------------------ AH Scenarios Summary: Wins Losses Ties Total Allies American 212 219 1 432 British & Commonwealth (a) 30 42 0 72 French 37 45 0 82 Russian 547 534 23 1104 Minor Allies (b) 30 43 0 73 Other Allies (c) 12 22 0 34 --------------------------------- Totals: 868 905 24 1797 Axis German 852 824 22 1698 Finns 14 10 0 24 Minor Axis (d) 9 5 0 14 Other Axis (e) 30 29 2 61 --------------------------------- Totals 905 868 24 1797 Overall Summary Wins Losses Ties Total Allies American 396 405 19 820 British & Commonwealth (a) 38 52 0 90 French 49 57 0 106 Russian 1198 1164 82 2444 Minor Allies (b) 36 50 0 86 Other Allies (c) 14 28 0 42 --------------------------------- Totals 1731 1756 101 3588 Axis German 1689 1679 99 3467 Finns 14 10 0 24 Minor Axis (d) 17 9 0 26 Other Axis (e) 36 33 2 71 --------------------------------- Totals 1756 1731 101 3588 Excluded scenarios 104 --------------------------------- Grand Total 3692 notes: (a) includes Canadians, Anzacs, Irish, South Africans, Indians, and any Nationality that uses British counters; (b) includes Poles, Yugoslavs Greeks, Norwegians, Danes, Dutch and Belgians before the conquest of their country; also includes Republican Spanish and Italians fighting on the Allied side after Italy's surrender in 1943; (c) when two of the other Allied nationalities are in the same scenario; (d) includes Croats, Slovaks, Hungarians, Bulgarians, Rumanians and Italians; also includes Nationalist Spanish, Japanese, North Korean, Chinese, Vietminh and Russians against Western powers; (e) when two of the other Axis nationalities are in the same scenario. ************************************************************************ Most-Played Scenarios (36 playings or more) (1% OR MORE OF TOTAL SCENARIOS REQUIRED) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 The Guards Counterattack 210 AL0 Alpha 0 (Forced March) 204 AL1 Alpha 1 (Forced March) 146 BE0 Beta 0 (Hasty Assault) 131 2 The Tractor Works 130 7 Buchholz Station 105 DE0 Delta 0 (Back to the Sea) 87 4 The Hedgehog of Piepsk 78 BE2 Beta 2 (Hasty Assault) 77 BE1 Beta 1 (Hasty Assault) 76 3 The Streets of Stalingrad 60 GTS1 Mirnaya Derevnya 58 BE3 Beta 3 (Hasty Assault) 58 AL2 Alpha 2 (Forced March) 58 GA0 Gamma 0 57 10 Hitdorf on the Rhine 56 5 Hill 621 55 GA1 Gamma 1 50 13 The Capture of Balta 50 AL3 Alpha 3 (Forced March) 47 14 The Paw Of The Tiger 39 ---- 1622 entries (43.93% of Record) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Most-Balanced Scenarios (50% to 55% balance, with 10 records or more) (numbers in parenthesis to the right of certain entries indicate the number of draws) 23 Silent Death Finnish 5 Russian 5 50.0% 31 Chateau de Quesnoy German 5 French 5 50.0% 7 Buchholz Station German 53 American 52 50.5% DE0 Delta 0 (Back to the Sea) German 43 American 44 50.6% BE3 Beta 3 (Hasty Assault) German 23 Russian 22 51.1% (13) 14 The Paw of the Tiger German 19 Russian 20 51.3% AL1 Alpha 1 German 71 Russian 75 51.4% 2 The Tractor Works German 63 Russian 67 51.5% 6 Escape From Velikiye Luki German 14 Russian 13 51.9% EP0 Epsilon 0 German 11 American 12 52.2% (8) CB1 Winterstorm in Tula German 9 Russian 8 52.9% 18 The Defense of Luga German 8 Russian 9 52.9% 108 Block Busting in Bokruisk German 8 Russian 9 52.9% AY04 Aachen Redoubt German 17 American 15 53.1% (6) AL0 Alpha 0 (Forced March) German 109 Russian 95 53.4% 26 Assault on a Queen German 7 Dutch 6 53.8% o46.3 Winter War German 11 Russian 13 54.2% GTS1 Mirnaya Derevnya German 21 Russian 25 54.3% 102 Slamming of the Door German 12 Russian 10 54.5% 201 Sacrifice of Polish Armor German 6 Polish 5 54.5% o35.1 Russia, 1941 German 17 Russian 14 54.8% Well-Balanced Scenarios (60% to 55% balance, with 10 records or more) --------------------------------------------------------------------- o60.1 The Workers Strike Back German 10 Russian 8 55.6% GA3 Gamma 3 German 10 Russian 8 55.6% T2 Pavlov's House German 8 Russian 10 55.6% 1 The Guards Counterattack German 93 Russian 117 55.7% GA2 Gamma 2 German 14 Russian 11 56.0% 13 The Capture of Balta Ger/Rum 22 Russian 28 56.0% 20 Breakout From Borisov German 8 Russian 6 56.7% (1) 10 Hitdorf on the Rhine German 32 American 24 57.1% 4 The Hedgehog of Piepsk German 45 Russian 33 57.7% o62.2 Mogilev German 7 Russian 5 58.3% 3 The Streets of Stalingrad German 15 Russian 25 58.3% (20) 19 A Winter Melee German 7 Russian 10 58.8% 29 In Rommel's Wake German 7 French 10 58.8% 8 The Bitche Salient German 14 American 20 58.8% BE2 Beta 2 (Hasty Assault) German 25 Russian 39 59.1% (13) 11 The St. Goar Assault German 12 American 8 60.0% WG101 Forced Entry German 9 Russian 6 60.0% WG103 Eviction Notice German 4 American 6 60.0% WG105 Patchwork German 6 Russian 4 60.0% Least-Balanced Scenarios (80% (im)balance, or more, with 10 records or more) ------------------------------------------------------------------------ 30 Ad Hoc at Beaurins German 8 British 2 80.0% *WG152 Patchwork German 2 Allied* 8 80.0% R214 The Front in Flames German 17 Russian 4 81.0% 106 Beachhead at Ozereyka Bay Ger/Rum 8 Russian 1 81.8% (2) 28 Counterstroke at Stonne German 13 French 2 86.7% 110 The Agony Of Doom German 13 Russian 2 86.7% 27 The Dinant Bridgehead German 9 French 1 90.0% 34 Climax at Nijmegen Bridge German 9 US/Bri 1 90.0% 205 Last Defense Line German 1 French 10 90.9% 12 The Road to Wiltz German 1 American 10 90.9% G Devil's Hill German 13 American 1 92.9%