| TEAM | ROUND 1 | TEAM | ROUND 2 | TEAM | ROUND 3 | TEAM | ROUND 4 |
| MAFIA | Mark Texaira | MAFIA | Doug waechter | MAFIA | Edgar Gonzalez | REDS* | Brian Reith |
| ORCAS | Brandon Webb | ORCAS | Oscar Villareal | ORCAS | Bo Hart | ORCAS | A Miles |
| RAIDERS | Rocco Baldelli | RAIDERS | Reed Johnson | RAIDERS | Brandon Claussen | RAIDERS | R Volgelsong |
| KNIGHTS | Miguel Cabrera | KNIGHTS | Laynce Nix | KNIGHTS | Grant Balfour | KNIGHTS | r Castro |
| PADRES | Jose Reyes | PADRES | Jesse Foppert | PADRES | Billy Traber | PADRES | d dellucci |
| MINUTEMEN | Dontrelle Willis | MUSKIES | Claudio Vargas | RAIDERS | Gerald Laird | TIGERS* | R Reyes |
| HURRICANES | Rickie Weeks | HURRICANES | Chin-hui Tsao | HURRICANES | J R House | HURRICANES | r calloway |
| REDS | Jerome Williams | KNIGHTS | Jimmy Gobble | MAFIA | Javier Lopez | INDIANS* | C eldred |
| CORGIS | Robby Hammock | CORGIS | Garret Atkins | CORGIS | Chad Cordero | CORGIS | M Neu |
| STAMPEDE | Rich Harden | STAMPEDE | Ramon Navar | STAMPEDE | Neal Cotts | STAMPEDE | R Freel |
| NIGHT TRAIN | Hideki Matsui | PADRES | Johnny Peralta | FRANSISCANS | Alex Escobar | FRANSISCANS* | A Melhouse |
| HURONS | Kahlil Greene | MINUTEMEN | Jose Valverde | MUSKIES | Chad Gaudin | HURONS | D kelton |
| ELECTRIC | Bobby Crosby | ELECTRIC | Aquilino Lopez | ELECTRIC | Rod Beck | ELECTRIC | T Mullholland |
| INDIANS | Horacio Ramirez | TIGERS | Chase Utley | INDIANS | Curt Leskanic | LUG NUTZ* | H Clark |
| IMPOSTERS | Luis Ayala | IMPOSTERS | David DeJesus | HURONS | Matt Roney | IMPOSTERS | R Olmedo |
| GIANTS | Matt Kata | GIANTS | Kevin Witt | GIANTS | Turk Wendell | GIANTS | Lenny Harris |
| CARDINALS | Edwin Jackson | LUG NUTZ | Rafael Betancourt | LUG NUTZ | Kevin Correia | HURONS* | L Martinez |
| MUSKIES | Jeremy Bonderman | MUSKIES | Steve Smitherman | MUSKIES | Todd Linden | MUSKIES | A perez |
| FRANSISCANS | Jody Gerut | FRANSISCANS | Jeremi Gonzalez | YANKEES | Fernando Rodney | FRANSISCANS | RA Dickey |
| WILD THINGS | Jose Contreras | WILD THINGS | Jason Kershner | WILD THINGS | Erasio Ramirez | WILD THINGS | K Calcero |
| NIGHT TRAIN | Justin Morneau | CUBS | Justin Duchsherer | HURRICANES | Aaron Heilman | NIGHT TRAIN | Passes |
| TIGERS | Ryan Wagner | TIGERS | Matt Riley | TIGERS | Wil Ledezma | TIGERS | R Madsen |
| NIGHT TRAIN | Gil Meche | MINUTEMEN | Dan Haren | LUG NUTZ | Dan Wheeler | CARDINALS* | K Pellow |
| TIGERS | Jason Bay | MAFIA | Andrew Good | TIGERS | Mickey Callaway | CARDINALS | D Dreifort |
| TEAM | ROUND 5 | TEAM | ROUND 6 | TEAM | ROUND 7 | ||
| MAM | Chris Capuano | CCR | S colyer | CLE | John Franco | ||
| WAO | J Standford | WAO | C barmes | WAO | K gryboski | ||
| RCR | k Gregg | RCR | N Robertson | RCR | J romero | ||
| NWK | J Depaula | SHH | L Terrero | NWK | E German | ||
| SDP | T Laker | NYY | J Duncan | SDP | M Ojeda | ||
| BSM | Dj Carrasco | SDP | S randolph | BSM | T Phelps | ||
| SHH | Jason Jones | SHH | C Ross | SHH | Griffiths | ||
| SHH | Rual Gonzalez | CLE | W Delgado | CCR | D sadler | ||
| YMC | L Ford | YMC | T Sears | YMC | C rivera | ||
| SSS | S Mirte | SSS | J Gomes | SSS | M Wood | ||
| NYY | F German | NYY | P Laforest | NYY | Raines | ||
| AAH | E Guzman | AAH | K Snyder | AAH | B Mcmillion | ||
| SCE | T Martin | SCE | M Lopez | SCE | Passes | ||
| CLE | J Valentin | CLE | D Bragg | CLE | Jason Boyd | ||
| IMP | SJ Stewart | IMP | Wellemyer | IMP | J Strong | ||
| SFG | Al Martin | SFG | O Merced | SFG | R Christiansen | ||
| LLN | D Turnow | LLN | J Santiago | LLN | Eric Eckenstahler | ||
| MAM | B Kieschnick | MAM | Jose Molina | MAM | E Cruz | ||
| FFF | D Klassen | FFF | g Koonce | BSM | S Mcclung | ||
| WWT | J Parrish | WWT | Raul chevez | WWT | C Magruder | ||
| MAM | R Quinlan | SNT | Passes | SNT | Passes | ||
| DET | N Punto | DET | J Dominquez | DET | J switzer | ||
| SNT | Passes | CHC | J Vitello | CHC | M Hessman | ||
| BSM | M Gallo | NYY | D Sanchez | CLE | T Miller | ||