| ROUND 1 | ROUND 2 | ROUND 3 | ||||||||
| TEAM | PLAYER | TEAM | PLAYER | TEAM | PLAYER | |||||
| 1 | Bellville Black Hawks | Delmon Young | 25 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Mike Napoli | 49 | South Haven Hurricanes | Taylor Tankersley | ||
| 2 | South Haven Hurricanes | Stephen Drew | 26 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Andrew Miller | 50 | Belleville Black Hawks | Josh Fields | ||
| 3 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Cole Hammels | 27 | Cincinnati Reds | James Shields | 51 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Scott Thorman | ||
| 4 | South Haven Hurricanes | Jared Weaver | 28 | South Haven Hurricanes | C B Young | 52 | Belleville Black Hawks | Ryan Sweeney | ||
| 5 | Indianapolis Imposters | Anibal Sanchez | 29 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Adam Lind | 53 | Indianapolis Imposters | Rheal Cormier | ||
| 6 | Cincinnati Reds | Russ Martin | 30 | Cincinnati Reds | Boof Bonser | 54 | Cincinnati Reds | Jake Woods | ||
| 7 | New York Yankees | Jeremy Sowers | 31 | New York Yankees | Scott Proctor | 55 | Belleville Black Hawks | Dustin Pedroia | ||
| 8 | San Francisco Giants | Adrian Gonzalez | 32 | San Francisco Giants | Alfredo Amazega | 56 | San Francisco Giants | Marcus Thames | ||
| 9 | Fisher Firemen | Ian Kinsler | 33 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Kevin Kouzmanof | 57 | Fishers Firemen | Joe Beimel | ||
| 10 | Baton Rouge Rajin' Cajuns | Nick Markakis | 34 | Baton Rouge Rajin' Cajuns | Mike Pelfrey | 58 | Baton Rouge Rajin' Cajuns | Erick Aybar | ||
| 11 | Madison Muskies | Josh Barfield | 35 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Luke Scott | 59 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Pat Neshek | ||
| 12 | Baystate Minutemen | Ronny Paulino | 36 | Ann Arbor Hurons | Takashi Saito | 60 | Baystate Minutemen | Eliezer Alfonzo | ||
| 13 | Newington Knights | Howie Kendrick | 37 | Newignton Knights | Jon Lester | 61 | Newington Knights | Chris Coste | ||
| 14 | Chicago Cubs | Kenji Johjima | 38 | Chicago Cubs | Pedro Feliciano | 62 | Chicago Cubs | Wes Littleton | ||
| 15 | Chicago Cubs | Andre Ethier | 39 | Baystate Minutemen | Ricky Nolasco | 63 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Ryan Theriot | ||
| 16 | Warrenville Wild Things | Melky Cabrera | 40 | Warrenville Wild Things | Macay McBride | 64 | Baystate Minutemen | Jonathan Sanchez | ||
| 17 | Columbus Crush | Chad Billingsley | 41 | Columbus Crush | Joe Saunders | 65 | Columbus Crush | Cha-Seung Baek | ||
| 18 | Washington Orcas | Joel Zumaya | 42 | Washington Orcas | Chris Iannetta | 66 | Washington Orcas | Scott Cassidy | ||
| 19 | River City Raiders | Matt Garza | 43 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Miguel Montero | 67 | River City Raiders | Charlie Haeger | ||
| 20 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Carlos Quentin | 44 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Lastings Milledge | 68 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Jose Garcia | ||
| 21 | Midwest Mafia | Adam Loewen | 45 | Midwest Mafia | Matt Kemp | 69 | Midwest Mafia | Carlos Ruiz | ||
| 22 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Dan Uggla | 46 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Jason Hirsh | 70 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Matt Albers | ||
| 23 | Madison Muskies | Troy Tulowitzki | 47 | Madison Muskies | James Loney | 71 | Madison Muskies | Carlos Villanueva | ||
| 24 | Detroit Tigers | Clay Meredith | 48 | Detroit Tigers | Adam Jones | 72 | Baystate Minutemen | Glen Perkins | ||
| ROUND 4 | ROUND 5 | ROUND 6 | ||||||||
| TEAM | PLAYER | TEAM | PLAYER | TEAM | PLAYER | |||||
| 73 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Matt Thornton | 97 | Baystate Minutemen | Shane Costa | 121 | Baystate Minutemen | Alexi Casilla | ||
| 74 | River City Raiders | Kendry Morales | 98 | Cleveland Indians | Ruddy Lugo | 122 | Cleveland Indians | Tim Corcoran | ||
| 75 | Fishers Firemen | Matt Diaz | 99 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Dave Aardsma | 123 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Brent Clevlen | ||
| 76 | South Haven Hurricanes | Jeff Baker | 100 | South Haven Hurricanes | Ryan Feierabend | 124 | South Haven Hurricanes | Tony Pena | ||
| 77 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Phillip Humber | 101 | Indianapolis Imposters | Fernando Nieve | 125 | Cincinnati Reds | Brandon Fahey | ||
| 78 | Midwest Mafia | Bill Bray | 102 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Ben Zobrist | 126 | Baystate Minutemen | Hong-Chi Kuo | ||
| 79 | Detroit Tigers | Matt Smith | 103 | Detroit Tigers | Jon Huber | 127 | Baystate Minutemen | Manuel Corpas | ||
| 80 | San Francisco Giants | Matt Capps | 104 | San Francisco Giants | Ryan Spilborghs | 128 | Belleville Black Hawks | Angel Guzman | ||
| 81 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Fausto Carmona | 105 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Brian Wilson | 129 | Fishers Firemen | John Koronka | ||
| 82 | Baton Rogue Rajin' Cajuns | Greg Norton | 106 | Baton Rogue Rajin' Cajuns | Darren Oliver | 130 | Baton Rogue Rajin' Cajuns | Tim Salmon | ||
| 83 | Madison Muskies | Manny Delcarmen | 107 | Madison Muskies | Yusmeir Petit | 131 | Belleville Black Hawks | Jim Johnson | ||
| 84 | Belleville Black Hawks | Shawn Hill | 108 | Baystate Minutemen | Brandon Lyon | 132 | Ann Arbor Hurons | Ron Mahay | ||
| 85 | Newington Knights | Sean Marshall | 109 | Newington Knights | Joel Guzman | 133 | Newington Knights | Enrique Gonzalez | ||
| 86 | Chicago Cubs | Elizardo Ramirez | 110 | Chicago Cubs | Jeff Salazar | 134 | Chicago Cubs | Alex Escobar | ||
| 87 | South Haven Hurricanes | Ubaldo Jimenez | 111 | Madison Muskies | Nick Masset | 135 | Indianapolis Imposters | Ryan Braun | ||
| 88 | Warrenville Wild Things | Mike Rivera | 112 | Warreneville Wild Things | Chad Parronto | 136 | Warrenville Wild Things | Brian Tallet | ||
| 89 | Columbus Crush | Zach Miner | 113 | Columbus Crush | Renyel Pinto | 137 | Columbus Crush | Carlos Marmol | ||
| 90 | Washington Orcas | Ramon Ramirez | 114 | Washington Orcas | Chris Sampson | 138 | Washington Orcas | Casey Janssen | ||
| 91 | River City Raiders | Josh Hammel | 115 | River City Raiders | Brian Bannister | 139 | River City Raiders | Rob Bowen | ||
| 92 | Baystate Minutemen | Chris Britton | 116 | Baystate Minutemen | Dana Eveland | 140 | Newington Knights | CJ Wilson | ||
| 93 | Midwest Mafia | Mike O'Connor | 117 | Indianapolis Imposters | Taylor Buchholz | 141 | Midwest Mafia | Vinny Rottino | ||
| 94 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Jason Windsor | 118 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Alberto Callaspo | 142 | Bellleville Black Hawks | Scott Moore | ||
| 95 | Springfield Streaking Stampede | Michael Bourn | 119 | Madison Muskies | Kevin Frandsen | 143 | Belleville Black Hawks | Jordan Tata | ||
| 96 | Baystate Minutemen | Saul Rivera | 120 | Detroit Tigers | Joaquin Arias | 144 | Detroit Tigers | Josh Sharpless | ||
| ROUND 7 | ||||||||||
| TEAM | PLAYER | |||||||||
| 145 | New York Yankees | Fabio Castro | ||||||||
| 146 | Warrenville Wild Things | John Rheinecker | ||||||||
| 147 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Scott Feldman | ||||||||
| 148 | Madison Muskies | Reggie Willits | ||||||||
| 149 | Cincinatti Reds | Carlos Martinez | ||||||||
| 150 | New York Yankees | Mike Thompson | ||||||||
| 151 | New York Yankees | Micah Bowie | ||||||||
| 152 | Warrenville Wild Things | Kason Gabbard | ||||||||
| 153 | Fishers Firemen | Brian Sweeney | ||||||||
| 154 | Baton Rouge Rajin' Cajuns | Russ Springer | ||||||||
| 155 | Madison Muskies | Brayan Pena | ||||||||
| 156 | Cleveland Indians | R Abercrombie | ||||||||
| 157 | Newington Knights | missed | ||||||||
| 158 | Chicago Cubs | Jack Cust | ||||||||
| 159 | Baystate Minutemen | Juan Mateo | ||||||||
| 160 | Cleveland Indians | Jason Tyner | ||||||||
| 161 | Columbus Crush | Tony Pena | ||||||||
| 162 | Washington Orcas | missed | ||||||||
| 163 | Cleveland Indians | Mark Lowe | ||||||||
| 164 | Fishers Firemen | Jon Adkins | ||||||||
| 165 | Midwest Mafia | Royce Ring | ||||||||
| 166 | Baystate Minutemen | Edward Mujica | ||||||||
| 167 | Madison Muskies | Joe Inglett | ||||||||
| 168 | Detroit Tigers | Jeff Kartsten | ||||||||