| # | ROUND 1 | PLAYER | # | ROUND 2 | PLAYER | # | ROUND 3 | PLAYER |
| 1 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Joe Mauer | 25 | Cincinnatti Reds | Noah Lowry | 49 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Chris Snyder |
| 2 | South Haven Hurricanes | David Wright | 26 | South Haven Hurricanes | Brad Hawpe | 50 | South Haven Hurricanes | Quillermo Quiroz |
| 3 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Zack Greinke | 27 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Adam LaRoche | 51 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Koyie Hill |
| 4 | Idianapolis Imposters | Scott Kazmir | 28 | Indianapolis Imposters | Jesse Crain | 52 | Baystate Minutemen | Gustavo Chacin |
| 5 | Schenectady Electric | Dallas McPherson | 29 | Schenectady Electric | Jon Lieber | 53 | Schenectady Electric | Dioner Navarro |
| 6 | River City Raiders | B J Upton | 30 | River City Raiders | Joe Blanton | 54 | River City Raiders | Gabe Gross |
| 7 | Madison Muskies | Casey Kotchman | 31 | Madison Muskies | Jose Capellan | 55 | Madison Muskies | Yhency Brazoban |
| 8 | Cincinnatti Reds | Daniel Cabrera | 32 | Cincinnatti Reds | Dan Meyer | 56 | Cincinnatti Reds | Luke Hudson |
| 9 | Spfld Streaking Stampede | Nick Swisher | 33 | Baystate Minutemen | Chad Tracy | 57 | Spfld Streaking Stampede | Victor Diaz |
| 10 | San Fransisco Giants | Luis A Gonzalez | 34 | San Fransisco Giants | David Newhan | 58 | San Fransisco Giants | Marco Scutaro |
| 11 | Baton Rouge Rajun' Cajuns | Gavin Floyd | 35 | Detroit Tigers | Scott Hairston | 59 | Baton Rouge Rajun' Cajuns | Victor Santos |
| 12 | San Diego Padres | Kaz Matsui | 36 | San Diego Padres | jeff francis | 60 | Baystate Minutemen | Kevin Youkilis |
| 13 | San Diego Padres | Grady Sizemore | 37 | Newington Knights | Ross Gload | 61 | Newington Knights | John Maine |
| 14 | Detroit Tigers | Alexis Rios | 38 | Detroit Tigers | Ryan Howard | 62 | Detroit Tigers | Brandon League |
| 15 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Matt Holliday | 39 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Termel Sledge | 63 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Shingo Takatsu |
| 16 | Warrenville Wild Things | Erik Bedard | 40 | Warrenville Wild Things | Charles Thomas | 64 | Cincinnatti Reds | Chris Young |
| 17 | Midwest Mafia | David Bush | 41 | Midwest Mafia | Jose Castillo | 65 | Midwest Mafia | Scott Elarton |
| 18 | Cleveland Indians | Bobby Madritsch | 42 | Newington Knights | Akinori Otsuka | 66 | Columbus Crush | Joey Gathright |
| 19 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Jeremy Reed | 43 | Cincinnatti Reds | JD Durbin | 67 | Livonia Lug Nutz | Jason Kubel |
| 20 | Columbus Crush | John Buck | 44 | Columbus Crush | Russ Adams | 68 | Columbus Crush | Jason Bartlett |
| 21 | Ann Arbor Hurons | Chris Burke | 45 | Ann Arbor Hurons | Jose Lima | 69 | Ann Arbor Hurons | Giovanni Carrara |
| 22 | Newington Knights | J D Closser | 46 | Baystate Minutemen | Brandon Backe | 70 | Chicago Cubs | |
| 23 | Washington Orcas | Yadier Molina | 47 | Washington Orcas | Jose Lopez | 71 | Washington Orcas | |
| 24 | Saint Louis Cardinals | Mike Gonzalez | 48 | Yorkville Mighty Corgis | Jorge Cantu | 72 | Newington Knights |