1952 Unknown

1953 Ed Monier

1954 Harley Conley

1955 Keith McKinney

1956 William Greenwood

1957 Marion Sias

1958 Wayne Thompson

1959 William Dabler

1960 Paul Pelley

1961 Bernard Casto

1962 Franklin Berresford

1963 Donald Davis

1964 Robert Campbell

1965 Robert Wagner

1966 Charles Cunningham

1967 Paul Boggess

1968 Robert Taylor

1969 Robert Kays

1970 Shirley Bradfield

1971 William McCallister

1972 James R. Starkey

1973 William Gotschall

1974 Jess Finley

1975 Dave Pethtel

1976 Donald Wolf

1977 Donald Poole

1978 Roger Crawford

1979 Dave Simms

2008

1980 Harvey Newlen

1981 Terry Stanley

1982 Harmon McKinney

1983 Richard Sell

1984 Francis Connor

1985 Richard Phillips

1986 Rexford Mays

1987 Sandy Bibbee

1988 David Keys

1989 Tom Jackson

1990 William Vincent

1991 Joseph Dowling

1992 Michael Blaner

1993 Timothy Simms

1994 Robert Tatgenhorst

1995 John Walsh

1996 Wayne Blake

1997 Randy Bogart­ of Wellsville Lodge #180

1998 Rod Meyers­ of Milton Lodge #256

1999 Randy Wolfe

2000 Shaun Thorn

2001 Mark Johnston

2002 Kenny Giusto

2003 Jack Linville

2004 Robert Santarelli

2005

2006

2007

 2009 - Jason Akers