What Would Letitia Baldrige Do?

First, I must tell you about Letitia Baldrige. She is an American author and expert in matters of taste, etiquette, and public relations. She served as public relations director for Tiffany and Co from 1956 to 1961. She then went on to serve as Jacqueline Bouvier Kennedy’s social secretary while the Kennedy’s were in the White House. I know; this woman is amazing. She actually worked at Tiffany’s while Blake Edwards was filming the phenomenal film Breakfast at Tiffany’s. Letitia even met Audrey Hepburn. How wonderful is that?
I like Letitia for several reasons. To give one example, I completely agree with her that civility and good manners can make the world a better place. Oh, and anyone who worked for Jacqueline Bouvier Kennedy wins a gold star from me. I could write a whole post about that and the fabulous Jacqueline Bouvier! Ok, let’s get back on track here. The one thing that bugs me about Letitia is the fact that she was born in the 1920s and raised during a time when women were expected to conform to certain societal rules—rules that were designed to keep the average American woman in a subordinate role. Now, I’m not saying that people who were born in the early 1900s should not be trusted; I’m just saying that her perspective may reflect a system of values that is no longer necessary in contemporary society. Below is a sample of her writing, taken from Letitia’s website.
Thinking Outward - Many people think manners are irrelevant today. It's just the opposite. They have never been more necessary for a peaceful, healthy society.Again, I couldn’t agree more. The practical significance of this concept is far-reaching. Making others feel comfortable and respected can do wonders for business and life! It’s surprising how many people fail to realize the importance of good manners.
Manners are not elitist or foppish. They are the way in which we interact with our fellow men and women. Much of the unhappiness, sadness and failures in the world today stem from those who go through life unaware of the importance of anyone else around them. They have no time for kindness.
Good manners result from thinking about someone else. They are a question of heart. That's it. The moment you wake in the morning or the minute you go outside the door of your home, the respect you show for the people around you, equals the quality of your manners. They are an exercise of the heart, not of money...
My former college roommate and I had an interesting conversation while we were both undergraduates in South Carolina. He, a true Southern gentleman, was from North Carolina. And we both agreed that some women, particularly women from the Northeast, hate for a man to hold the door open for a woman. Why is that? I’m sure Ms. Baldrige would consider that quite appropriate. My roommate even encountered a woman who became annoyed by this very gesture. Let’s just say, if looks could kill, my friend would be dead.
There are, of course, other examples, and I could go on and on about this topic. But I’ll conclude by saying that times have changed. I was raised in a family that expects all of its members to adhere to certain rules of propriety. I just can’t help but wonder if these rules are no longer necessary. And my biggest concern is that these societal rules may be doing more harm than good (e.g., subordination of women).
Click here to listen to Letitia Baldrige on the popular NPR program Wait Wait . . . Don't Tell Me!

4 Comments:
It depends for whom you hold the door open. My momma would love it. She fondly recalls a distant time when gentlemen treated a lady with deference and respect. These days they barrel right over her, or so she tells me. The last man never saw her as he was rushing down the hallway. She said that if she hadn't stepped aside he would have bumped into her, and since she is recovering from hip surgery, that could have been devastating. In another instance, two men walked towards her on the sidewalk outside an airport terminal. Neither got out of the way. My mother, with two replaced knees, had to step off the curb in order to let them pass.
So, I think one must judge the situation as it comes. Little old ladies have frailties that must be taken into account; so do pregnant women; as do men on crutches. It's a matter of being polite to one another, not because of sex but because it makes living in this world easier.
That young lady who scowled at your friend for opening the door? Shame on her. She should have thanked him sweetly, then walked ahead of him and opened the next door and let him pass (this is what I do - tit for tat). Or, if she could not have returned the favor for your friend, she might have opened the door for the next guy.
Good post, Marius. Fruit for thought.
First let me say...I love Wait Wait...Don't tell me! It's my Sunday afternoon laughter. Ha!
As for these women walking around with a huge chip on their shoulders about the sexual roles in society...I offer this statement: Guess what? We're different!
Whether we like to admit it or not we as a female gender are different...we respond differently to things than men, we physically are different (we can create life inside our bodies..how cool is that), we handle our daily lives differently (women can, in general, mulitask better than men). Why would we want to be the same?
One of my favorite exampes of how women being different works better then being the same is Bunny McDoogle...Charlotte York's mother-in-law on Sex and the City. Like her or not she knew how to get her way...a simple gesture of putting her hand on her son's arm and making a "suggestion" got her everything she wanted in life...and she was a woman who wanted her door opened for her. This is how women through the ages have handled outwardly appearing to be the "subordinate sex"...everyone knew it. Just look at all of Jane Austen's books (kisses to Ms. Place) the women were always "in charge". They were always the dominate figures. Instead of that girl thinking that your friend opened the door for her because she couldn't do it herself why didn't she think..."Hey, I got that guy to open the door for me."
I think this whole disappearance of social graces and the gender divide have made for confusion within society as well as sexes. Do I think women should have equal rights, pay, job promotion....absolutly. But do I also think that men should still open doors, pullout, chairs, etc and women should still accept graciously offering appreciation and not scorn...damn straight. Too bad for your friend that he seemed to run into one of these sad souls who can't accept kindness as just that...kindness. He does society good by opening that door and I for one give him a big gracious smile.
Aw, I missed "Wait Wait" this week.
These days I think both men and women can hold doors open for anyone. I see women hold doors for men and men hold doors for other men. I think that's a nice way to be polite without being sexist.
Thanks, everyone, for your insightful comments. I have more to say about this. Stay tuned! :)
Post a Comment
<< Home