Mary Lincoln “Tinty” Martin

Mary Lincoln Martin, the eleventh of the fourteen children of Nathaniel Martin and Hannah Strader, was born 12 August 1863 in Martintown, Green County, WI. Obviously named after the nation’s then-current First Lady, she was known to the family as Tinty. It is not known how she obtained such an unusual nickname, which sometimes appears in family correspondence as Tintie and Tinta, except that it might somehow have come from her middle name. How one gets “Tinty” from “Lincoln” is a mystery, but the nickname was part of a set shared with her brother Abraham Lincoln Martin, the set being Linky and Tinty. Perhaps Tinty evolved from an earlier version, Tinky being the prime possibility.

Tinty and Linky were a tandem of sorts in childhood, though the 1870s was very much a time when boys did boy stuff and girls did girl stuff. It must have been quite a shock to Tinty when her brother drowned in the Pecatonica River in 1879 at only eighteen years of age.

Tinty married Elwood Byron Bucher 30 January 1882 in Monroe, Green County. Elwood was often better known as E.B. Bucher. The eldest son of Jacob Bucher of Pennsylvania and Matilda Gilbert of Maryland and one of many children, Elwood had been born 14 February 1861 in Amboy, Lee County, IL. He had spent his childhood there and in adjacent Ogle County before the family came north to Jordan Township, Green County, WI prior to 1880, by which time he was almost old enough to be out on his own. His father worked for years as a miller, and had apparently passed those skills along to Elwood, who at the time of the wedding was a miller working at the Martin grist mill.

Tinty (shown at right at about age seven) was one of the youngest children of Nathaniel and Hannah, so it was only natural that her own children were among Nathaniel and Hannah’s youngest grandchildren, and there are strong indications Hannah doted on them. The matriarch had plenty of opportunity to do so because Tinty remained emotionally and geographically close to her parents. Tinty and Elwood and their brood dwelled first right in Martintown and then, some time in the 1890s, moved only a tiny bit south over the state line to Winslow, Stephenson County, IL. (Shown below at right is their home a hundred years after they moved into in it.) Tinty and Elwood had the five children whose biographies can be found by clicking on their names at the bottom of this page, as well as a set of male twins, born 25 September 1890 in Martintown. No source provides a name for either of the twins, who were probably born prematurely as twins often are. This lack of known names implies they died very early in their infancies. However, it is believed they were not stillborn, or their existence would probably not have been noted at all. Instead, they are referred to in family genealogical notes and in Elwood’s obituary. The 1900 census plainly states that Tinty had given birth seven times and confirms that two had died. Their birthdates were not recalled within the family, but by 1890, Green County was beginning to make a practice of keeping birth records on file, and so the Wisconsin Birth Index was used to determine when they came into the world. Whether either or both of the twins survived past the 25th is not yet known.

Tinty survived a greater number of years than eight of her siblings. Nevertheless, she did not escape the curse of short lifespan. She passed away at the age of only thirty-nine, her death taking place 1 September 1902 in Winslow. Her death record states she perished of peritonitis and salpurgitis, complicated by septic metritis. In layman’s terms, her upper reproductive tract became severely infected. However, at that point in medical history, it was common for women’s deaths to be attributed to reproductive tract sepsis when actually the problem was a burst appendix. Either way, if Tinty had lived in the era of surgery and antibiotics, she need not have succumbed. That makes her death seem particularly tragic to those of us who are alive today, but it was tragic enough at the time. Imagine the horror of Nathaniel and Hannah, to know that they had survived more than half the children born to them. Tinty was the penultimate child of the couple to be laid to rest in the private Martin cemetery at the crest of the hill above her parents’ house. (Her gravemarker is shown below left.) Her brother Horatio’s body would be interred there less than four years later.

Tinty and then Horatio’s demise set the stage for their surviving spouses, Elwood Bucher and Laura Hart Martin, to find solace from their loneliness in each other. They would marry 21 March 1907 in Chicago, meaning that the children of Tinty and Horatio would henceforth be not only first cousins, but step-siblings.

Elwood slipped easily into the role of boss of the Martin mills. He moved into the home Laura and Horatio had shared. In the long run Laura would be his wife over a greater period than Tinty had been. The couple finished raising Laura’s youngest three children as well as Ralph Bucher, who had only been two years old when his mother died. The other Bucher kids did not participate in this shared household because by early 1907 they were old enough to have established themselves independently, even Blanche, who was a school teacher soon to marry Tecumseh E. Claus. Inasmuch as Elwood and Laura’s home was right next door to that of Hannah Strader Martin, they surely provided some care to the elderly widow, though the brunt of this responsibility fell upon Juliette Martin and her husband E.E. Savage, who had moved back to Martintown and back into the original Nathaniel Martin family residence after some years spent in the Pacific Northwest.

Elwood was the last major steward of the family legacy business. That he was the last was not due to any failure on his part. In fact, he seems to have been a particularly capable successor of Nathaniel and Horatio, and this competence was a good thing, because he faced challenges from the early days of his tenure. He was not allowed the luxury of simply letting the businesses operate as they had over the previous half-century and more. The globalization and consolidation of commerce was wiping out cottage industries right and left. The production of flour had once been a matter of local farmers growing their own wheat and bringing it to the nearest mill to be processed. Lumber had once been delivered by ox-drawn wagons and barges, and the shorter the distance the wood had to travel from forest to mill to construction site, the better and cheaper for all concerned. Nathaniel Martin had in a sense enjoyed a monopoly. But by 1905 to 1910, the operations he had brought into being were becoming quaint. Old customers would still come calling, but only if the prices remained competitive with those of the large, distant suppliers. Elwood did not stand idly by and let himself be a victim of changing times.

Elwood embraced the new era, seeing new opportunities. At this point, it was taken as a given that electricity would soon be the standard way every American home would be lit. Electrical appliances -- stoves, refrigerators, vacuums -- were poised to become equally common, if not quite so soon. In Martintown and Winslow, there was as yet no electrical utility company. Elwood saw that he could tap the power of the mills’ waterwheels and meet that demand. In 1909 he was awarded a contract by the town of Winslow to supply enough electricity in the evenings for the street lights, allowing the gas lights to be retired. By September of that year -- a month ahead of deadline -- he delivered on his promise. The power plant eventually became the mills’ prime reason to exist, ahead of flour and lumber.

Elwood’s main assistant was Charles Lewis Buss, the husband of his daughter Rose Marie Bucher. Elwood was reaching fifty years old and as he saw it, Charles would make an ideal successor. Other young males of the family were tapped to help with the business, whether it be flour milling or lumber cutting or running the electrical plant. These included Fay Martin and later, as teenagers, Ralph Bucher and Clark Martin. Having Charles on hand, living with Rose and their offspring a stone’s throw from the huge mill buildings, meant Elwood was free to move back to Winslow, so as the “aught” years of the 20th Century turned into the 1910s, he and Laura and their boys did so. Life had become secure again, with a seeming bright future ahead, after a very trying decade that had opened with the death of Tinty, seen the deaths of Nathaniel and Horatio and the departure of Nellie Martin Warner and most of her family, and had ended with the demise of Arley’s young husband Frank Ritter.

The good times lasted only about five years, then Elwood’s doctor son Claude passed away in late 1915 while making a house call. At the end of 1918, Blanche succumbed to the great influenza epidemic. Both died in their early thirties. About 1920, Elwood’s health failed. The precise nature of his malady is not well described in surviving notes, but he often resorted to a wheelchair during the 1920s (though he was capable of standing upright, as shown in the photo at left, with Laura outside their home). Grandson Lyle Smith recalled that as an adolescent he was not allowed to see Grandpa Elwood because he had some sort of “bad disease.” This may have meant Elwood had a condition that was contagious or unsightly, tuberculosis being the prime candidate, or it could mean he had something morally repugnant, such as syphillis (which would explain why much of Elwood’s care fell to his brother John, who moved into the Winslow home with Elwood, Laura, and their “grown-sons-still-at-home” Fay and Ralph, Clark having moved to Washington state). Whatever it was, it was chronic. Extended forays to the South and the West, taken in hope of therapeutic benefit, did nothing to help.

Elwood’s one comfort as he entered this last decade of his life might have been the thought that he had left the family businesses in the custody of a hand-picked, well-trained successor. Alas, Charles Buss chafed at the role he was asked to play. He longed to do something else with his life. Among other things, he wanted to become a clergyman. Rose, too, felt the calling to preach, unusual though that was for a woman of her generation. In the early 1920s, Charles lost three fingers in an accident at the mills. He took this as a sign that he was not living the life meant for him. Charles and Rose moved to a new home in Vermilion County, IL, near Danville. Possible family replacements such as Ralph or Fay, or Laura’s grandsons Leon and Lyle Smith, did not have the aptitude or inclination -- or in the case of the Smith boys, the experience -- to steer the business into the future. A competitor electrical utility eventually acquired the mills and kept the electrical plant going through the 1940s.

Elwood resigned himself to spending his dwindling time as an invalid at his home, where he finally expired 6 March 1930 of pneumonia and heart inflammation. His remains were interred at Rock Lily Cemetery, Winslow.

Children of Mary Lincoln Martin with Elwood Byron Bucher

Claude Earl Bucher

Arletta Pearle Bucher

Rose Marie Bucher

Blanche B. Bucher

Ralph Byron Bucher

For genealogical details, click on each of the names.

To return to the Martin/Strader Family main page, click here.