Bruce Jenner Fantasia
Dennis Rodman Fantasia
Banger Sisters Idol Cougars
Lisa Edelstein Jason Castro
(Credit to TonyD at the HTF)
Major Arnold Toht David Archuleta
Comic Book Guy David Cook
Bill Cosby Syesha Mercado
Bob Hoskins Jeff Archuleta
Archaic Smile statue David Archuleta
Chimpanzee David Cook
Archduke Franz Ferdinand Dan Snarr
The Grinch Syesha Mercado
Jonah Hex David Cook
Jafar Bo Bice
Sindel (from Mortal Kombat) Amanda Overmyer
Frankenstein's Monster David Cook
The Bride of Frankenstein Amanda Overmyer
Vanilla Ice Ryan Seacrest
Alfred E. Neumann David Archuleta
Orangutan David Cook
Rene Descartes Paula Abdul
Bill Murray David Cook
New York Syesha Mercado
Howard Dean David Cook
Reese Witherspoon Syesha Mercado
Hedwig Brooke White
E.T. The Extra Terrestrial Andrew Lloyd Webber
Apu David Cook
Sigmund Paula Abdul
Tin Tin Ryan Seacrest
The Wall David Cook
Troll Doll David Archuleta
Elasti-Girl Carly Smithson
Horseshoe Crab Jason Castro
Horse Carly Smithson
Kristy Lee's Horse David Cook
Talosian David Cook
Alfred Hitchcock David Cook
Shroud of Turin Chikezie
Whoopi Goldberg Jason Castro
Orangutan David Cook
Big Bird Brooke White
Drusilla Carly Smithson
Alien Syesha Mercado
Rogue Amanda Overmyer
Forrest Whitaker Chikezie
Butthead Danny Noriega
Danny Bonaduce David Archuleta's Father
Barn Owl Kristy Lee Cook
Bugs Bunny Carly Smithson
Cirque Du Soleil Clown Asia'h Epperson
Alfred Hitchcock Simon Cowell
Gary Coleman Chikezie
Bride of Chucky Amanda Overmyer
Hermey the Elf Colton Berry
Huey Freeman Syesha Mercado
Jessica Alba Danny Noriega
Heat Miser
Richard Simmons
Jorja Fox
Sleestack