Library Postcards: Civic Pride in a Lost New York

As promised, divided. NYPL and other New York City public libraries have their own page.

Carnegie Libraries

Unlike many states, there is no large website that lists all the New York libraries. New York appears to differ from many states in that its library districts correlate with its school districts.

 Amsterdam

Amsterdam, NY Carnegie Library

1902 Carnegie grant. Still in use.


Valentine & Sons card, mailed in 1911. Compared with the photo on the city's website, the colors are quite accurate.



 Binghamton

Binghamton Carnegie Library Binghamton Carnegie Library

1902 Carnegie grant. Now known as the Broome County Public Library, and is still in use.

(L) Monochromatic, mailed in 1905.
(R) Unusually, this card was printed in Great Britain. Mailed 1910.





 Catskill

Catskill Carnegie Library

1901 Carnegie grant.
On this card, the Neoclassical building covered with ivy is the library. The light colored building is the Masonic Temple.


The library does not seem to be in as bucolic a setting today.


 Canastota

Canastota Carnegie Library

Founded 1896 and moved into this Carnegie building in 1903, according to the library's exuberant web site. Not listed as a Carnegie building in Bobinski.

The full history page adds such wonderful tidbits as the original price of the lot ($900) and the 1951 replacement of 'antiquated' library furnishings during the first major renovation.


 Dunkirk

Dunkirk, NY Carnegie Library Dunkirk, NY Carnegie Library

I believe that this is the Chautauqua County Dunkirk, both from on-line clues and from the message on the card (L). This library was well-established before the 1904 Carnegie grant.
I do not know its current function.

(L) The card was printed in Germany for S.H. Knox & Co., and mailed in 1909.
(R) Never-mailed Albertype card, made in Brooklyn.

 Elmira

Elmira, NY Carnegie Library

For now, I'm taking the word of the Rubin Bros. that this is a Carnegie Library. However, Steele Memorial Library appears to be the current Elmira facility. The 1923 - 1979 library would have been built too recently to be a Carnegie building. More information is clearly needed.




 Far Rockaway, Long Island

Far Rockaway, NY Carnegie Library

Also not listed by Bobinski as a Carnegie building. Incorporated into the Queens library ca. 1907, and some time later, replaced.

Plain brick building with a policeman in front. Postcard mailed in 1906.




 Gloversville

Gloversville, NY Carnegie Library Gloversville, NY Carnegie Library

Two views of a fascinating Beaux Arts building. The arch reads Gloversville Free Library; immediately above the door reads 'Carnegie.'
(L) Valentine & Sons' Publishing post card, mailed 1913.
(R) Unattributed German card with unevenly divded back, mailed in 1908.

1904 Carnegie facility, designed by Albert Randolph Ross. It was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1976. The library was in grave financial trouble in the mid-2000s, was chartered by the New York Board of Regents, and changed to being the Gloversville Public library.


 Johnstown

Johnstown, NY Carnegie library

1902 Carnegie facility, renovated in 1995.


Arty monochrome view by the Rochester News Company.





 Kingston

Kingston, NY Carnegie library

Bobinski's Carnegie Libraries lists Kingston as recipient of a 1902 grant. However, the library appears to be in a 19th century building today.

 Mt. Vernon

Mt. Vernon, NY Carnegie library

Bobinski's Carnegie Libraries lists Mt. Vernon as recipient of a 1901 grant.

 New Rochelle

New Rochelle Public Library

1901 grant according to Bobinski, but the Library's web history places it sometime between 1910 and 1914. 1928 addition dated from 1928. Replaced in 1979: fate unknown.

Atypical Curt Teich linen card dates from 1934.



 Niagara Falls

New Rochelle Public Library

1901 grant. Replaced in 1974, and is still standing.
Curiously, Niagara Falls, Canada also received a Carnegie grant.

The card is unattributed and lacks even a plate number.



 Nyack on Hudson

Nyack Public Library

1901 grant, still in use.

Beautiful building of river rock and dressed stone. Under the awning, shown on the library's site, is a clearly Romanesque entryway.

This is an Excelsior card, printed in Germany.



 Patchogue, Long Island

Patchogue, LI Carnegie library

Built from a 1905 grant. Now known as the Patchogue-Medford Library. I don't know if the building is still in use.

Unusual card with a red border more typical of scenic view cards.





 Penn Yan

Penn Yan Carnegie library

Founded in 1895. Built from a 1903 grant, in 1905. The original library is still in use.


Lovely Rotograph card printed in Germany.






 Perry

Penn Yan Carnegie library

1912 grant. Built in 1914, and still in use. An addition houses an art gallery.


1935 Curt Teich linen finish card.






 Port Jervis

Pt. Jervis, NY Carnegie building

Card also features the Port Jervis Elks Club.


1901 grant. The Free Public Library is still in use, serving the residents of the Port Jervis School District. It is part of the Ramapo Catskill Library System.






 Schenectady

Schenctady Carnegie Library

This card is in quite poor condition, but there's just something about being able to work 'Schenectady' into a paragraph.

1903 Carnegie facility, also aided by a grant from General Electric. Replaced ca. 1969: the library now heads the Mohawk Valley Library Association.

The building is now a dormitory for Union College. I find that a rather amusing reuse.

 Syracuse

Syracuse Carnegie Library Syracuse Carnegie Library Syracuse Carnegie Library
Early chrome card,
imported by C.E. Wheelock of Peoria.
German card, from H.C. Leighton. From the 'Syracuse series.'
Syracuse Carnegie Library Syracuse Carnegie Library

This Beaux Arts building served as the Syracuse Public Library, 1905-1976. Today it has been superceded by the Onondaga County Public Library.
The Carnegie building's fate is unknown to me, despite one of the best library history timelines ever.
Did you know Onondaga County PL began to use plastic cards in 1978? If you guessed right about that, do you remember its bookmobile recall by Chrysler?

1979, by the way.

Syracuse University also has a Carnegie library, serving as the Science and Technology Library.

 Warsaw

Warsaw, NY Carnegie building

1904 grant. Per the Library's site, its architect was Albert Randolph Ross. Opened in 1906. Still in use, after a 1991 renovation.

The Earle H. Parker photo doesn't display the curved nature of the front very clearly on the Albertype card.
The script at top reads:
George Yoron built it your mother
Cousin
It was addressed to R.P. Stack of Rockford.



Non-Carnegie Libraries

 Attica

Attica, NY library

After remodeling, the 1893 building serves as the Stevens Community Memorial Library.

 Auburn (Case Memorial Library)

Case Memorial Library

Now known as the Seymour Public Library District. Designed by Carrere and Hastings. Opened in 1903 and expanded in 1973 and 1993.

Published by C.S. (not F.W.) Woolworth and Co., with an entire back.
Mailed in 1909.



 Batavia (Richmond Memorial Library)

Richmond Memorial Library

Wow. Simply wow.

This is the first Romanesque library building I've seen that looks as if it had had librarians in on the design. Unfortunately, there appears to no longer be a public library in this town, going by the Libweb list.

This is a Valentine & Sons card, mailed in 1912.

 Boonville (Erwin Library)

Erwin Library Erwin Library

Built in 1890.
Now known as the Erwin Library and Institute, part of the MidYork Library System.

(L) Card mailed in 1907.
(R) 1957 Dexter Press. This is one of those library postcards that could be sent as a Christmas card.



 Canandaigua (Historical Museum and Wood Library)

Historical Museum and Wood Library

The Wood Library today appears to be in an older, smaller building. It is neither about Wood nor in a wood building.






 Canton (Benton Library)

Benton Library

Founded 1887. Built sometime between 1907 and 1910, and expanded in 1956. Renovated in 2006.

The card has a pencil date range as Sept.--May 1917-18.






 Deposit

Deposit Free Library

Founded just prior to the stock market crash in 1929. Opened in 1937. Expanded in 1962.

Photo postcard with typed caption.






 East Hampton, Long Island

E. Hampton, LI Library

Bears a solid resemblance to Highland Park, Illinois' Carnegie Library.
The Library's web site describes it as 'Neo-Elizabethan.' It was built in 1912, with Aymar Embury serving as its architect.

The 'Eagle Quality' card was mailed in 1937.





 Friendship (Pitt Memorial Library)

Pitt Memorial Library

Named for William Pitt, oil geologist.

Although the portico is lettered 'Pitt Memorial Library,' the glass window over the door reads 'Friendship Free Library.'
So act sullen, morose, and unhelpful.

Valentine-Souvenir postcard.





 Johnson City (Your Home Library)

Your Home Library

In my collection, certainly the card from the library with the oddest name . It was mailed in 1924 but appears to be about a dozen years older. It was published by A.M. Pierson of Binghamton, N.Y.






 Lockport

Lockport, NY Library Lockport, NY Library

(L) Linen-finish card
(R) 1956 Curt Teich chrome card.

Built in 1935 - 6.
Over the door: Books*Are*Like*An*Open*Door*To*Set*The*Spirit*Free,
attributed to Edith Kathleen Jones, a Massachusetts librarian.



 Malone (Wead Library)

Wead Library of Malone, NY

Still in use. In reality, the brickwork is in variegated brown shades.
Since 1954, it's part of the Clinton Essex Franklin Library System.

This is a linen-finish, Tichnor Quality View. It's not quite as high quality as the Curt Teich cards it emulates.





 Middletown (Thrall Library)

Middletown, NY library

Organized in 1801.
Bleak ca. 1901 building, replaced in 1995. However, the card has some fun details. The lady in blue is reading and walking.

An MLS thesis was written in 1996, by Barbara C. Chumard, about this library.

 Montour Falls

Montour Falls Library

Not listed in Bobinski's Carnegie Libraries (1969).

The building is still in use, and the library is part of the Southern Tier Library System.



 Ogdensburg

Ogdensburg Library

Now, with green shutters!
(But, no history on its web page.)

1937 Curt Teich linen-finish card.



 Pleasantville

Pleasantville Library

Flemish architecture, rare in the library world.

Looks more like a book cover illustration than a library. The card is by the Tecraft Company.

Now part of the Mount Pleasant Public Library.



 Poughkeepsie (Adriance Memorial Library)

Adriance Memorial Library Adriance Memorial Library

(L) Forbidding card by Leighton & Valentine.
(R) Card by J. Ruben of Newburgh. The retoucher enhanced the dome's resemblance to a muskmelon.

The library is quite clearly still in use.




 Red Hook

Red Hook Library

Building designed by Orson Squire Fowler.

The library took over the house in 1935. New York and New England seem to have a lot of libraries utilizing former mansions.




 Richfield Springs

Richfield Springs Library Richfield Springs Library

(L) Simply lovely Albertype card.
(R) 1915 Curt Teich card, with information, 'Given by Mr. T.R. Proctor.'

Part of the Four County Library System.
There's not a lot of information out there about this library's history.




 Rochester (Rundel Memorial Building)

Rochester Library Rochester Library

Slightly Deco.

(L) 1936 Curt Teich linen-finish card.
(R) Metropolitan card, mailed 1953.

Now joined by the Bausch & Lomb Public Library Building to comprise the headquarters of the Monroe County Library System.




 Rome (Jervis Public Library)

Jervis Public Library, Rome, NY

I believe this to be the original building, John B. Jervis' home, which was converted to a public library in 1895, and upsized in 1925.
Yes, I'm aware that no-one upsized anything in 1925.
It was enlarged yet again in 1961, 1972, and 1988.




 Sherburne

Sherburne Public Library

Originated as part of Sherburne Free Academy. Current building designed by Edward Tilton in 1909. Its current roof is green tile, and it was built using red brick.
South wing added, 1939; renovations, 2002.

Part of that south wing is visible on the card, which was mailed in 1968.

 St. Johnsville (Margaret Reaney Memorial Library)

Margaret Reaney Memorial Library

Built in 1909, and still in use after a 1936 addition.

 Southampton (Rogers Memorial Library)

Rogers Memorial Library

Replaced.

Tomlin Art Card.

 Utica

Utica, NY Library Utica, NY Library Utica, NY Library

Library still in use.
Very detailed library history. My favorite line:

1895 -- A handwritten card catalog is started. It takes three years to complete and totals 58,000 cards.

I thought typing catalog cards was laborious!

 Walton (William B. Ogden Free Library)

Wm. B. Ogden Free Library

Here is another aluminum postcard. (The other--of Hallowell, ME's library--is in the New England pages, and is in much better condition.)


However, I found a wonderful virtual tour of this 1899 structure. What really impresses me is this is the same gentleman who served as the first mayor of Chicago (1837-8), and for whom Ogden Avenue (US 34) is named. From postmaster of a Catskills village to the top position in the Second City: simply amazing. And on his 1877 death, he left funds for his hometown to have a new library building.





 Warwick, Orange Co. (Albert Wisner Memorial Library)

Albert Wisner Memorial Library

Unfortunately, someone tried to include the post office on the 1968 card.
In early 2011, this building was sold to the Warwick Historical Society.

 Waterloo

Waterloo, NY library

Still in use. The building also includes the Historical Society.

 Watertown (Roswell P. Flower Memorial Library)

Roswell P. Flower Memorial Library Roswell P. Flower Memorial Library

Library's file of the dedication booklet.

Grecian-style library finished in 1901 and evidently still in use.

(L) Curt Teich American Art Colored Card mailed in 1926.
(R) Valentine and Sons' card printed in Great Britain. Never mailed, but probably older than that on the left.



 Westfield (Patterson Library)

Patterson Library, Westfield, NY

Without slope to its roof, just how many books were lost due to leaks?

Contains the notes: From Curteich--'Gift of Miss Hannah W. Patterson, containing 44,000 Volumes in memory of her parents.'
From the purchaser--'Arrow under window at far right points to basement entrance to Girl Scout Little House.'



Mystery libraries of New York

None appears on Bobinski's list of Carnegie libraries.

Newark

West Point

Author's comments

To the best of my knowledge, the majority of these cards has reached the public domain by virtue of the postcards' age. I claim full copyright on the text, which may be used in citation only. Also, I claim copyright on the scans.

If you have evidence that any of the non-Carnegie cards are really of Carnegie libraries, please e-mail me at (first name)(at)roadmaps (dot) org.

© 2007 - 2012 Judy Aulik

Updated 20 March 2012.
Go down east to New England libraries.
Return to home page.