| Best Rookie Pitcher | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Doc White | 12-3 2.95 |
| 1901 National League | Bill Duggleby | 13-4 3.22 |
| 1901 American League | Norwood Gibson | 18-9 2.62 |
| 1902 National League | Pop Williams | 10-8 3.74 |
| 1902 American League | Chief Bender | 13-11 2.63 |
| 1903 National League | Beany Jacobson | 13-9 3.78 |
| 1903 American League | Jimmy Dygert | 19-7 2.23 |
| 1904 National League | Nap Rucker | 15-12 3.05 |
| 1904 American League | Joe Lake | 17-15 3.62 |
| 1905 National League | Ed Summers | 13-16 3.31 |
| 1905 American League | Walter Johnson | 15-9 2.21 |
| 1906 American League | Vive Lindaman | 11-16 2.48 |
| 1907 National League | Bob Harmon | 9-18 4.06 |
| 1907 American League | Ray Collins | 16-14 1.86 |
| 1908 National League | Pete Alexander | 14-14 3.28 |
| 1908 American League | Larry Cheney | 9-14 2.61 |
| 1909 National League | Rube Marquard | 11-15 2.77 |
| 1909 American League | Cliff Curtis | 4-13 3.79 |
| 1910 National League | Bugs Raymond | 10-9 2.72 |
| 1911 National League | Babe Adams | 16-6 3.15 |
| 1911 American League | Hank Robinson | 4-5 2.60 |
| Gold Glove (P) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Jack Powell | 1.000 |
| 1901 National League | Jack Chesbro | 1.000 |
| 1901 American League | John Brackenridge | 1.000 |
| 1902 National League | Tom Thomas | 1.000 |
| 1902 American League | Stan Yerkes | 1.000 |
| 1903 National League | Roy Evans | 1.000 |
| 1903 American League | Andy Coakley | 1.000 |
| 1904 National League | Kaiser Wilhelm | 1.000 |
| 1904 American League | Chick Robitaille | 1.000 |
| 1905 National League | Slim Sallee | 1.000 |
| 1905 American League | George McQuillan | 1.000 |
| 1906 National League | Jake Boultes | 1.000 |
| 1906 American League | Ed Siever | 1.000 |
| 1907 National League | Harry Coveleski | 1.000 |
| 1907 American League | Russ Ford | 1.000 |
| 1908 National League | George Kahler | 1.000 |
| 1908 American League | Lew Richie | 1.000 |
| 1909 National League | Doc Scanlan | 1.000 |
| 1909 American League | Bob Spade | 1.000 |
| 1910 National League | Gene Packard | 1.000 |
| 1910 American League | Hippo Vaughn | 1.000 |
| 1911 National League | Big Jeff Pfeffer | 1.000 |
| 1911 American League | Barney Pelty | 1.000 |
| Gold Glove (C) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Frank Chance | 1.000 |
| 1901 National League | Chief Zimmer | 1.000 |
| 1901 American League | Jack Ryan | .993 |
| 1902 National League | Klondike Douglass | 1.000 |
| 1903 National League | Ed Phelps | 1.000 |
| 1904 American League | Harry Bemis | 1.000 |
| 1905 American League | Tom Needham | 1.000 |
| 1906 National League | Admiral Schlei | .998 |
| 1906 American League | Ira Thomas | 1.000 |
| 1908 National League | Red Dooin | 1.000 |
| 1908 American League | George Gibson | 1.000 |
| 1909 National League | Chief Meyers | .997 |
| 1909 American League | Larry McLean | 1.000 |
| 1910 National League | Ed Phelps | .989 |
| 1910 American League | Peaches Graham | .996 |
| 1911 National League | Bill Rariden | 1.000 |
| 1911 American League | Ira Thomas | .998 |
| Gold Glove (1B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Dan McGann | 1.000 |
| 1901 National League | Fred Tenney | .999 |
| 1901 American League | George Stovall | 1.000 |
| 1902 National League | Dan McGann | .999 |
| 1902 American League | George Stovall | .998 |
| 1903 National League | Dan McGann | 1.000 |
| 1903 American League | Kitty Bransfield | .997 |
| 1904 National League | Dan McGann | .999 |
| 1904 American League | Frank Isbell | .998 |
| 1905 National League | Jake Stahl | 1.000 |
| 1905 American League | Tom Jones | .998 |
| 1906 National League | Dan McGann | 1.000 |
| 1906 American League | John Anderson | .995 |
| 1907 National League | Dan McGann | 1.000 |
| 1907 American League | Frank Isbell | .998 |
| 1908 National League | Ed Konetchy | 1.000 |
| 1908 American League | Jake Daubert | 1.000 |
| 1909 National League | Ed Konetchy | .991 |
| 1909 American League | George Stovall | .986 |
| 1910 National League | Ed Konetchy | .990 |
| 1910 American League | Jake Daubert | .991 |
| 1911 National League | Dick Hoblitzell | .991 |
| 1911 American League | Jake Daubert | .993 |
| Gold Glove (2B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Nap Lajoie | .988 |
| 1901 National League | Miller Huggins | .996 |
| 1901 American League | Harry Arndt | .998 |
| 1902 National League | Hobe Ferris | .996 |
| 1902 American League | Billy Gilbert | .996 |
| 1903 National League | Claude Ritchey | .994 |
| 1903 American League | Harry Arndt | .994 |
| 1904 National League | Miller Huggins | .991 |
| 1904 American League | Harry Arndt | .993 |
| 1905 National League | Miller Huggins | .993 |
| 1905 American League | Eddie Collins | .995 |
| 1906 National League | Hobe Ferris | .996 |
| 1906 American League | Harry Arndt | .990 |
| 1907 National League | Claude Ritchey | .988 |
| 1907 American League | Harry Arndt | .992 |
| 1908 National League | Miller Huggins | .995 |
| 1908 American League | Germany Schaefer | .994 |
| 1909 National League | John Hummel | .945 |
| 1909 American League | Eddie Collins | .938 |
| 1910 National League | John Hummel | .956 |
| 1910 American League | Eddie Collins | .952 |
| 1911 National League | John Hummel | .957 |
| 1911 American League | Jim Delahanty | .957 |
| Gold Glove (3B) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | John McGraw | .989 |
| 1901 National League | Jimmy Collins | .985 |
| 1901 American League | Andy Oyler | .979 |
| 1902 National League | Lave Cross | .987 |
| 1902 American League | John Godwin | .983 |
| 1903 National League | Lave Cross | .987 |
| 1903 American League | Emil Batch | .987 |
| 1904 National League | Jimmy Collins | .997 |
| 1904 American League | Lee Tannehill | .986 |
| 1905 National League | Ernie Courtney | .988 |
| 1905 American League | Dave Brain | .989 |
| 1906 National League | Ernie Courtney | .981 |
| 1906 American League | Bill Coughlin | .983 |
| 1907 National League | Jimmy Collins | .982 |
| 1907 American League | Harry Lord | .985 |
| 1908 National League | Wid Conroy | .967 |
| 1908 American League | Harry Lord | .977 |
| 1909 National League | Art Devlin | .960 |
| 1909 American League | Eddie Grant | .938 |
| 1910 National League | George Moriarty | .948 |
| 1910 American League | Harry Lord | .947 |
| 1911 National League | Heinie Zimmerman | .962 |
| 1911 American League | Frank Baker | .950 |
| Gold Glove (SS) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Herman Long | .996 |
| 1901 National League | Bill Dahlen | .991 |
| 1901 American League | Terry Turner | .993 |
| 1902 National League | George Magoon | .996 |
| 1902 American League | Freddy Parent | .991 |
| 1903 National League | Bobby Wallace | .995 |
| 1903 American League | Terry Turner | .992 |
| 1904 National League | Joe Tinker | .989 |
| 1904 American League | Freddy Parent | .989 |
| 1905 National League | Joe Tinker | .995 |
| 1905 American League | Terry Turner | .993 |
| 1906 National League | Al Bridwell | .992 |
| 1906 American League | Mickey Doolan | .996 |
| 1907 National League | Joe Tinker | .993 |
| 1907 American League | Jim McGuire | .988 |
| 1908 National League | Phil Lewis | .987 |
| 1908 American League | Bobby Wallace | .972 |
| 1909 National League | Joe Tinker | .942 |
| 1909 American League | Bobby Wallace | .939 |
| 1910 National League | Joe Tinker | .959 |
| 1910 American League | Donie Bush | .937 |
| 1911 National League | Joe Tinker | .950 |
| 1911 American League | Heinie Wagner | .934 |
| Gold Glove (LF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Jimmy Barrett | .991 |
| 1901 National League | Topsy Hartsel | 1.000 |
| 1901 American League | Jim Delahanty | 1.000 |
| 1902 National League | Topsy Hartsel | .995 |
| 1902 American League | Lou Bruce | .998 |
| 1903 National League | Fred Clarke | .979 |
| 1903 American League | Davy Jones | .998 |
| 1904 National League | Topsy Hartsel | .998 |
| 1904 American League | Dutch Meier | .997 |
| 1905 National League | Sherry Magee | .996 |
| 1905 American League | Bris Lord | .995 |
| 1906 National League | Sherry Magee | .998 |
| 1906 American League | Roy Hartzell | .995 |
| 1907 National League | Sherry Magee | .992 |
| 1907 American League | Rube Oldring | 1.000 |
| 1908 National League | Sherry Magee | .991 |
| 1909 National League | Rube Ellis | .963 |
| 1909 American League | Roy Hartzell | .986 |
| 1910 National League | Bill Collins | .987 |
| 1910 American League | Birdie Cree | .985 |
| 1911 National League | Bert Daniels | .992 |
| 1911 American League | Chick Gandil | .971 |
| Gold Glove (CF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Chick Stahl | .991 |
| 1901 National League | Ginger Beaumont | .993 |
| 1901 American League | Tommy Dowd | .996 |
| 1902 National League | Chick Stahl | .991 |
| 1902 American League | Steve Brodie | .998 |
| 1903 National League | George Van Haltren | .987 |
| 1903 American League | Rip Cannell | .996 |
| 1904 National League | Jimmy Barrett | .988 |
| 1904 American League | Dave Fultz | 1.000 |
| 1905 National League | Shad Barry | .987 |
| 1905 American League | Rip Cannell | 1.000 |
| 1906 National League | Fred Snodgrass | .997 |
| 1906 American League | Al Burch | 1.000 |
| 1907 National League | Johnny Bates | .997 |
| 1907 American League | Charlie Jones | .996 |
| 1908 National League | Johnny Bates | .995 |
| 1908 American League | Harry Armbruster | .998 |
| 1909 National League | Dode Paskert | .988 |
| 1909 American League | Al Burch | .988 |
| 1910 National League | Fred Snodgrass | .990 |
| 1910 American League | Al Burch | .973 |
| 1911 National League | Fred Snodgrass | .987 |
| 1911 American League | Clyde Milan | .962 |
| Gold Glove (RF) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Honus Wagner | .990 |
| 1901 National League | Honus Wagner | .996 |
| 1901 American League | Charlie Hemphill | .998 |
| 1902 National League | Honus Wagner | .998 |
| 1902 American League | Charlie Hemphill | 1.000 |
| 1903 National League | Honus Wagner | 1.000 |
| 1903 American League | Mike Mitchell | 1.000 |
| 1904 National League | Honus Wagner | .993 |
| 1904 American League | Red Murray | 1.000 |
| 1905 National League | Honus Wagner | 1.000 |
| 1905 American League | Mike Mitchell | .998 |
| 1906 National League | Harry Lumley | .998 |
| 1906 American League | Doc Gessler | 1.000 |
| 1907 National League | Honus Wagner | .998 |
| 1907 American League | Doc Gessler | 1.000 |
| 1908 National League | John Titus | .995 |
| 1908 American League | Doc Gessler | .998 |
| 1909 National League | Chief Wilson | .977 |
| 1909 American League | Red Murray | .969 |
| 1910 National League | Frank Schulte | .994 |
| 1910 American League | Doc Miller | .983 |
| 1911 National League | Frank Schulte | .990 |
| 1911 American League | Doc Gessler | .967 |
| Silver Slugger (C) | ||
| Year/League | Player | Stats |
| 1900 National League | Ed McFarland | .284 1 22 |
| 1901 National League | Boileryard Clarke | .298 25 70 |
| 1901 American League | Sport McAllister | .320 3 43 |
| 1902 National League | Klondike Douglass | .278 4 55 |
| 1902 American League | Harry Bemis | .302 10 53 |
| 1903 National League | Ed Phelps | .291 1 54 |
| 1903 American League | Tom Needham | .313 3 69 |
| 1904 American League | Harry Bemis | .266 4 69 |
| 1905 American League | Tom Needham | .271 4 42 |
| 1906 National League | Roger Bresnahan | .300 11 78 |
| 1907 National League | Tubby Spencer | .261 7 46 |
| 1907 American League | Nig Clarke | .287 0 49 |
| 1908 National League | Roger Bresnahan | .280 1 33 |
| 1908 American League | George Gibson | .232 1 36 |
| 1909 National League | Red Dooin | .207 1 48 |
| 1909 American League | George Gibson | .258 0 47 |
| 1910 National League | Johnny Kling | .291 4 71 |
| 1910 American League | George Gibson | .260 4 45 |
| 1911 National League | Ted Easterly | .337 3 62 |
| 1911 American League | Larry McLean | .294 1 61 |