"Politics!"
This is the rallying cry of the defenders of Bill & Hillary Clinton in the
myriad scandals swarming around them like yellowjackets on a campground
dumpster. Given that they are, after all, politicians, and that their accusers
are politicians, and that Whitewater is taking place in the political arena,
this taunt carries much less ballast than one would think. The question to be
asked is "Are they guilty as charged?"
"But,"
say their defenders, "they haven't been charged with anything!" Which
is both true and false, depending on the local context. They have yet to be
publically indicted, though a sealed indictment against Mrs. Clinton reputedly
sits on Kenneth Starr's desk, waiting to be activated. But that doesn't seem to
register with the Clintonoids; in fact, nothing does. The Whitewater trail,
which would make breadcrumbs look like T-bone steaks if it led to a
Republican's doorstep, makes rice cakes look appetizing as far as Friends of
Bill are concerned. To this day, they still insist that "there's nothing
there."
Despite all the
denials and professions and demurrals, the suspicions persist. Why? Because Clinton
and his wife seem to "know" all the wrong people.
Mrs. Clinton denied
ordering the Travel Office firings, and Mr. Rodham denied even knowing about
them. David Watkins - not coincidentally a leading figure in the Clinton-Gore
'96 re-election campaign - tried manfully to take the rap. But the first couple
is intimately acquainted with Hollywood producer and travel-company poobah
Harry Thomason, who wanted the Travel Office business for himself, and who met
twice with the President the week before the purge, and...well, you can fill in
the rest.
The First Couple
deny any involvement in the shady dealings surrounding Whitewater Development
Co. (WDC) and the Castle Grande development. Yet they not only knew, but were
bosom buddies with, all the other principle suspects and indictees in the
affair. Both Clintons were equal partners with Jim & Susan McDougal in WDC,
and profited when Mr. McDougal absorbed their share of the losses from the
scam. Mrs. Clinton did interest-conflicting legal work for Mr. McDougal,
including answering RTC interrogatories. Her husband talked Mr. McDougal into
putting her on a $2,000 per month retainer, as well as soliciting campaign
contributions from Madison Guaranty in exchange for gubernatorial
"favors." The Arkansas Securities Commissioner to whom Hillary took her
legal plan for recapitalizing the foundering thrift, Beverly Bassett, had been
appointed by Bill only three months earlier. David Hale, the Arkansas judge who
copped a plea in exchange for cooperation with Special Prosecutor Kenneth
Starr, was known by Clinton, who pressured him to make a
"questionable" $300,000 loan to Madison, and thence to WDC.
Perhaps Mrs.
Clinton did hit the jackpot in cattle futures, but she did receive
"advice" from a friend, Tyson Foods Counsel Jim Blair, which proved
to be almost "miraculous" in its precocity. Blair was clearly a man
whose knack as a handicapper went beyond pork bellies.
But while the
prosaica of Arkansas business and financial mores are getting a long-overdue
national airing, the list of Clinton chums does not stop at the edges of the
underworld. They also "know" a gentleman by the name of Arthur Coia,
and know him very well.
Coia was all but
born into organized crime. His father was regional boss of the Laborers'
International Union of North America (LIUNA), which the junior Coia joined at
the tender age of fourteen, and a lifelong friend of New England mafia
godfather Raymond Patriarca, a connection which, assert federal investigators,
ensured the Coias' lifelong success.
When the elder
Coia, then #2 official in LIUNA, was felled by a stroke in 1989, Arthur Coia
bid to succeed him. He was given the post on the condition of his acquiescence
to the Mafia's takeover of LIUNA's presidency. When the mob-picked president
died in February 1993, Coia was named by the General Executive Board to the top
spot.
A RICO
investigation of LIUNA was initiated by the FBI clear back in 1988, and learned
all kinds of things about how the union was being run:
--Rank & file
members have no say in the internal election process. If reformers win control
of a local, Coia can bury them under a mob-controlled district council.
--Local bosses,
like Dominick Lopreato of Hartford, CT, regularly take bribes to mismanage
union pension funds and invest them in [Does this sound familiar?] shady real
estate deals. Such schemes have drained tens of millions of dollars from
pension and benefit funds, leading to the discontinuance of medical payments
for members, dependents, and widows.
--Reformers who
challenge the ruling order are threatened, intimidated, fired, assaulted, and
sometimes, outright murdered.
Coia's primary
responsibility upon assuming LIUNA's presidency was to stonewall the Justice
Department's investigation to the greatest extent humanly possible. For the
next two years, according to federal investigators, he did nothing to disrupt
Mafia control despite numerous prosecutions and media exposes of corruption. He
refused to impose a trusteeship on New York City's Mason Tenders District
Council, one of LIUNA's biggest mob cesspools. Rather, he reimposed a
gangster-dominated district council on Local 435 in Rochester, NY, which had
been freed of Mafia control in 1986 and had been prospering under the
leadership of Bob Brown, an African-American who started as a ditchdigger and
built his own construction business.
Arthur Coia's most
powerful allies are not Mafia capos, killers, and enforcers, however. They are Sick
Willie and Mrs. Clinton.
Coia, recognizing
kindred spirits when he saw them, curried favor with the incoming Clinton
Administration right away. LIUNA made a $100,000 loan to the President-Elect's
inauguration committee. Coia was the only major union boss to defy the AFL-CIO
and back passage of NAFTA. He enthusiastically supported Clintoncare. His PAC,
the Laborers' Political League, poured $1.2 million into Democratic coffers for
the 1994 election. In June 1994 he hosted a ritzy DNC fundraiser that lined
Democrat pockets to the tune of $3.5 million more.
Rather than openly
disavow this de facto bribery, or at least keep their distance, the Clintons
reciprocated warmly. He is a White House regular these days. He has shared
breakfast (and God knows what else) with Hillary, attended receptions with
foreign dignitaries, ridden around on Air Force One, and was named to the
committee to select the site for the 1996 Democratic National Convention. Coia
even goes along on campaign trips.
Clinton-Coia
correspondence is equally as obeisant. "Dear Arthur," Mr. Bill wrote
on 4 November 1994, "I just heard you've become a grandfather - Congratulations!
Thanks for the gorgeous driver - it's a work of art. Best, Bill." Another
such note not long after thanked Mr. Coia for his support of Democratic
candidates and actually promised to share his views on labor with Labor
Secretary Robert Reich (which would be redundant).
The same day as the
aforementioned "Dear Arthur" letter, the Justice Department delivered
a 212-page RICO civil suit to Coia's D.C. headquarters. It charged him and
co-conspirators with employing "actual and threatened force, violence, and
fear of physical and economic injury to create a climate of intimidation and
fear." Coia was accused of "systematic abuse" of Laborers'
rights by "intimidating [them] into silence by violence, threats of
violence, economic coercion, and by the known ties of local and international
union officials with organized crime." LIUNA attempts to counter and
settle the suit ran up against one non-negotiable demand: "Coia has to
go."
LIUNA attorneys
appealed this deadlock over the heads of the Justice Department's Organized
Crime and Racketeering Section to Clinton-appointee Jo Ann Harris, assistant
attorney general for the Criminal Division. The demand was dropped.
Still, such was the
sheer weight of the government's case that Coia and LIUNA's Executive Board had
to at least make the appearance of cleaning house. But, in a pattern strongly
reminiscent of the Clintons' own stalling tactics, LIUNA's defense team adopted
a strategy of delay. Mafia-controlled Chicago and New York regional VPs were
suspended - temporarily. An "inspector-general" post was to be
created, though it would not be independent, but answer to the Executive Board.
Despite all of
this, Mrs. Clinton went to Miami Beach, FL in February 1995, gave a speech to
top LIUNA officials, and posed for photographs with Coia. A week later, the
Justice Department caved in to Coia completely, fully allowing him to
"police" his own operation. Seven months passed with (surprise!) no
changes, no reforms, just business-as-usual. Finally, last September, Acting Assistant
Attorney General John Keeney, a non-Clintonoid, delivered an ultimatum to Coia:
give members the right to elect their officers, or we'll take over. Coia lawyer
Brendan Sullivan, Jr.'s smug retort? "The decision to implement the
consent decree will be made by the [PERMANENT} Assistant Attorney General"
- who has yet to be named.
People are known by
the company they keep. From Arkansas con-artists to avowed Mafiosos, Bill &
Hillary Clinton travel in less than reputable circles, and have been for years.
If they can't get their protestations of innocence to be taken seriously, it's
their own damn fault.
But the weight of
evidence is squarely against them.