Progress on The Model by December 2006

We've made a lot of progress since my last update! Unfortunately I haven't any photos to post (yet), but they're coming.

We've run trains to the end of track, just inside the west portal of the Nay Aug Tunnel! By that point the entire "typical train" (15 feet long, or three six-axle diesels, about nineteen 50- and 60-foot cars, and a caboose) is on the grade, so I've had a chance to do some tractive effort testing, with mixed results. My goal is to balance grade, motive power tractive effort, and car weight so that a "typical" train will not be able to make the grade without at least one, but preferably two, helpers.

Preliminary testing suggested increasing the grade substantially would accomplish that goal, so we revised part of the grade so the entire distance is about 3.5%. Unfortunately when I tested the grade with a train of NMRA-standard-weighted cars, three locos pulled it up with ease. Darn those smooth-running, powerful locos! I tried several loco types with similar results. Reducing the number of locos improved things, of course, but two locos could still usually pull the train -- even after careful tuning of the rolling stock's trucks, replacing plastic wheels with metal, etc. Reducing the weight of the locos helped a little but not enough. I considered removing motors and gears from one of the locos to create non-powered units, but elected not to make such drastic modifications to the locos.

Finally, I adjusted the car weights. Although this approach requires modification of every car, installing the weight in a removable container makes it relatively reversible, and I prefer this approach to modifications to the locomotives. After testing several weights, I found that a train of 19 cars weighing 8 ounces each met my requirements. Since the NMRA-standard weight for a 50 foot car is approximately 4.5 ounces and a 60-foot car should be about 5 ounces, this requires adding 3 to 3.5 ounces per car. I plan to fine-tune the car weights to more closely align car length and weight, and still need to consider how to approach TOFC and autoracks, but it's a start.

 

That's all for now.  Feedback and comments are welcome!
Send your thoughts to jwmutter@yahoo.com Thanks!