Cable Provider Monopoly  

Comparison of cost and effectiveness between 
Rail, Bus and Auto  


Comparison of cost and effectiveness between 
Rail, Bus and Auto

Home• SMART & MARIN TRANSIT • Transit Plan Truths • Countywide Plan • SR Gen Plan • San Quentin • Mosquitos & West Nile Virus • Cable Provider Monopoly • Insurance Companies in marin • MTC Spending Transit v Highway • CA Transportation Plan 2050 • Feedback • Books & Links •

AT&T, after being taken over by Comcast, is forcing all of its broadband internet users to convert their email address from @ATTBI.com to @COMCAST.net.  This follows the same upheaval of its customers from @HOME.com to @ATTBI.com only 2 years ago. (They took over @Home's broadband internet business and forced them out of business.  @Home was totally dependent on the Cable Companies' monopoly of their customer's subscription).

So now is a good time to
remove the county's residents from over dependence on the county's cable Provider "du jour" by establishing a domain that will stay with the County's cable internet users forever. AT&T must be forced to offer an independent email- address-domain so that, (should the county decide to change its cable Provider), the Provider  cannot cite the address-change-disruption as a reason NOT to. The address-change-disruption being:-  Everyone HAS to change email addresses to that of the new cable Provider.
(Change the county resident's broadband domain to @MARIN.com ?)

(Don't let AT&T tell you that its not technically possible)

The Cable (and Satellite) Provider must make clear its intention and goals. It must NOT put companies like TIVO, ReplyTV and Moxi out  of business by exercising their monopoly of set-top box scrambling and Channel Program Information. (see below) The county must insist on this before renewing its license.

DVR companies need to be able to control changing channels on the set-top box and know of Cable TV channel programming.

And ensure that Cable (and Satellite) Providers' deals with TIVO, don't put ReplayTV and others out of business. (TIVO is part owned by NBC and other networks).

The Cable Companies' scrambling cable Box is a monopoly which must adhere to public standards in input/output (incl. wireless) to encourage competition in attached devices.
 Adding recording features to the cable or satellite box threatens both the stand-alone digital video recorder (TIVO, ReplayTV) and integrated entertainment hubs built around the home computer. The stand-alone digital recorder is facing stiff and possibly insurmountable challenges. 
http://www.reardenstudios.com/articles/ieee_feb0702.html

For the same reason, Cable Cos. must also make their Channel Info public and any changes instantly available.


ReplayTV has a new DVR that includes a broadband connection. The modem enables the downloading of content onto the receiver's hard drive. Expect ReplayTV, TiVo and others to launch video on demand services by 2003. The broadband modem will turn the DVR from a recording machine into a movie machine.
Cable companies can bankrupt this competition by "proprietizing" their set-top box and not disclosing Channel Info.

You will soon be undocking your notebook PC from a docking station where it was recording TV shows and movies from the previous day/night and then watch them while commuting on the bus to work....There's some transit motivation!

 
Consumers don't want stacks of set-top boxes and they don't want cable spaghetti behind their TVs. But Cable Set-Top Boxes can be infinitely smaller than they are and can be "slotted into" whatever other entertainment hub needs to interface with them, if Government forces them to do so. This includes the inevitable day when it will be slotted into the home computer. It too will be totally interfaced with the TV .  There will only be ONE remote control, an alpha-numeric keyboard, accessing both the PC and TV. All of today's Set-Top Box functionality will be software on the PC. The Cable Company must own the Scrambling Chip ONLYAnd as Disney tries to add yet another set-top box for ITS Movie-on-Demand service look for an Unique ID on the PC to facilitate ALL of the different pay services that will abound.

Every major set-top-box manufacturer is readying a device that will act as a home media server. These machines will track your consumption habits and help you find movies, music. They will screen out advertising. They will feed content to your stereo system, your personal computer, and additional television sets.
EchoStar Satellite hopes to have boxes with Moxi software in the hands of its customers by the end of the year. If Moxi's demonstrations are any indication, these multitalented boxes will be a reminder of what cable subscribers are missing by not getting a dish. That's a choice cable doesn't want its customers to make.

July 25, 2000    http://news.com.com/2100-1040-243625.html
Comcast cable customers in two New Jersey areas will soon be able to lease, instead of buy, a digital video recorder.
Under separate deals announced today, Comcast customers in Cherry Hill, N.J., will be able to try out a TIVO digital video recorder, while customers in Burlington County will be offered the same from rival ReplayTV.
Where is Marin's offering?

In both cases, consumers will be able to get the units at no up-front cost. Instead, a monthly fee will be added to their cable bills. Both machines allow consumers to record their favorite TV programs onto hard disks instead of having to use videotape.

Adding TiVo or ReplayTV service is important for the cable companies because satellite TV operators have already moved to add such features to their offerings.

The ReplayTV service will cost $11.95 per month. TiVo's monthly fee is not final yet but will probably be about $19, according to Edward Lichty, director of business development for TiVo. The cost difference reflects the fact that TiVo typically charges a $9.95 monthly service fee while ReplayTV users pay only for hardware.

I cancelled Cable and took the DirecTV alternative. It includes 3 rooms - one with TIVO,for $279. The same cost of a standalone TIVO. Calling the Cable Company to cancel they said I would have to pay $14 more per month for my Broadband Internet (from $49 to $64 ! ). When I said I would cancel that and go for DSL they immediately offered me an alternative - keep Basic Cable for a special price of $6 per month and avoid the $14 alternative. I am pissed that not until I threatened to go DSL did they make this offer. (Note that DirecTV TIVO has 2 tuners and the standalone TIVOs only one. I can be recording 2 programs whilst watching a 3rd, stored program.)

 
• SMART & MARIN TRANSIT • Transit Plan Truths • Countywide Plan • SR Gen Plan • San Quentin • Mosquitos & West Nile Virus • Cable Provider Monopoly • Insurance Companies in marin • MTC Spending Transit v Highway • CA Transportation Plan 2050 • Feedback • Books & Links •    
Questions or problems regarding this web site should be directed to MarinInfo@comcast.net.  
Last modified: Sunday August 20, 2006.