Monster Mash
The Cary Loren Interview
Cary Loren didn't just see the future of rock and roll¾ in many ways, he helped create it. Beginning nearly three decades ago, his first project, Destroy All Monsters, paved the way for such anti-music noisemongers as Throbbing Gristle, Test Dept., Half Japanese, and Pere Ubu. Their tales of potheaded pixies ('Pothead Speaks'), necrophilia ('I Love You But You're Dead'), sci-fi ('To Planet M2-40'), 'Vampires,' politics ('Assassination Photograph'), and other pick-me-ups about drugs ('Acid Monster') and death ('You Can't Kill Kill' and 'You're Gonna Die') were outraging audiences and clearing rooms a year before Lou Reed's "fuck you" to the industry, "Metal Machine Music" even hit the shelves, and they were one of the first bands in America to approximate the chaotic anarchy of krautrockers, Can, Amon Düül, and Faust. Fans of Suicide and Nine Inch Nails will also find much to admire in the confrontational theatrics of DAMs early stage shows. Loren and his girlfriend (and DAM vocalist), Niagara, along with bandmates, Jim Shaw and Mike Kelly were also responsible for one of the first fanzines, Destroy All Monsters magazine, which included drawings, band bios, reviews, interviews, and collages of comics, adverts, and photos from old magazines from the '40s/'50s. They produced six issues between 1974-79, a compilation of which is available (through Loren's Book Beat Gallery) as Destroy All Monsters; Geisha This.
As punk music began its ascendancy in the mid-'70s, DAM were aligned with its anarchic, political rantings and ravings, although most journalists failed to realize that DAM were no mere bandwagon-jumpers; they had, in fact, been doing this for years. Many of their early pieces remind me of the later "no wave" music of NY scenesters Gina Harlow, Lydia Lunch/Teenage Jesus & The Jerks, James Chance & The Contortions, and similar acts championed by Eno on his "No N.Y." collection and its "No L.A." West Coast counterpart. Most of the confusion seems to stem from the fact that it was a later incarnation (following a personnel change which saw ex-Stooge Ron Ashton and ex-MC5 drummer Mike Davis kick Loren out of his own band) that is familiar to most listeners. During our extensive interview, Cary told me, "Jeff, I'm glad you've never heard DAM¾ most people haven't and its reputation is somewhat inflated from its association with the Stooges and MC5. There is a 3xCD set of our work from 1974-1976 that would be good to score if you can find a copy¾ a seminal avant art/rock/noise treat." More about that in a minute. Thankfully, the original line-up (sans Niagara) recently reformed, and several live "reunion tour" releases have trickled out of Loren's End is Here homegrown label: "Grow Live Monsters," "Backyard Monster Tube," and "Silver Wedding Anniversary." They've also released their first new studio album in over 25 years, "Swamp Gas," so fans can re-discover the original band in all its glory. The curious are also advised to seek out that aforementioned 3xCD retrospective from the original line-up, "Destroy All Monsters 1974-1976," co-released by fan Thurston (Sonic Youth) Moore's Ecstatic Peace and Byron Coley's Father Yod imprints. [It should also be noted that Loren repaid Thurston's longtime support by dedicating "Confessions" (from his latest project, Monster Island's debut release, "From The Michigan Floor") to Sonic Youth.]
Following the DAM debacle, Cary hooked up with Barry Roth to form Nightcrawlerz. Finding inspiration from the cut-up techniques of Brion Gyson and William S. Burroughs, Loren and Roth retired to their basements and, with the aid of broken tape machines, cheesy keyboards, an assortment of pots and pans, and an overactive imagination, proceeded to create a pastiche of political commentary, answering machine messages, excerpts from TV shows and old films, and an occasional atonal "song" or two¾ years before Beavis and Butthead and Mystery Science Theatre 3000 hit the airwaves, or Bongwater entered a studio.
In recent years, Loren has joined forces with Warn Defevre (His Name Is Alive), Erika Hoffman (Godzuki), and Matt Smith (Outrageous Cherry) to form another Detroit supergroup, Monster Island. Combining elements of the acoustic folk/psych of Incredible String Band, the wyrdfolk of Stone Breath, the Iditarod, and Six Organs of Admittance, and the gothic, fairytale romance of Goblin Market, MI (which, nominally, incorporates both DAM and the abbreviation for their beloved home state of Michigan) add nursery-rhyme lullabies and exotic instrumentation (shakahachi, bells, violins, djembe, Gamelan gender barung (huh?), tanpura, sitar, oud, etc.) to forge yet another notch in Loren's musical bonnet.
With the simulataneous releases of DAMs "Swamp Gas," "The Third Mind" (a 2xCD Nightcrawlerz retrospective), and two MI disks ("Peyote Mind" and "Dream Tiger")¾ all on Loren's The End Is Hear imprint¾ our very own monster, Jeff Penczak contacted Cary at his Book Beat store for the following monster mash. We begin by asking about one of the more colorful tracks on the recent 3xCD DAM retrospective…
Destroy All Monsters
'Pothead Speaks'¾ a little bit of "method
singing" there, getting into the appropriate character before you recorded
that?
Not to sound insensitive, but if Niagara wasn't your girlfriend at the time,
would she have figured in your plans when you were assembling the band? Did you
always envision it as a quartet with a female as the upfront, vocal
representation of the band?
To be fair, DAM probably couldn't have happened without her. I was doing film
and theater happenings at the time we were living together, and she invited her
classmate Mike Kelley to one of those events. (They met each other on a bus on
their first day of drawing classes at U of M [University of Michigan].)
Mike brought his roommate Jim Shaw to check us out, and that was the beginning…the band sort of assembled itself when we got together¾ she really didn't figure into it, but she was a main catalyst for it to happen. On our first live performance she didn't get a chance to sing¾ they threw us out as we were warming up! It was also very hard to get her to sing, she was incredibly shy, she was really more of a visual focal point…something to look at, like a statue. People came and gawked at her in vintage wedding gowns splattered with fake blood. She did some creative outfits, early goth-style. She took tips from Morticia in The Addams Family and Edie Sedgewick, her fave superstar….
She really did almost nothing but stand there and powder her face white¾ but she had a look...beautiful, exaggerated makeup, freaky cloths and weird hair-colors¾ we all wore gross ugly outfits, really derelict. I think we were inspired by the group photo on "Trout Mask Replica"¾ we loved that album.
I never thought of DAM as a traditional band: guitars and up-front singers. We cursed everything traditional…. I liked the idea that anybody could join or play in DAM, we had a sort of "open door" policy.
Sorry I asked!
No, I wasn't offended by your question. I do not like nor dislike Niagara,
and sometimes wish we had never hooked up¾ but then
DAM and other things might not have happened.
Did she join you for the reunion tour?
Yeah she played the first three gigs¾ the last
one almost ended in a riot. She's mainly interested in doing boogie-rock. I
don't think the art rock/noise approach goes down well with her¾
and that's OK¾ we've always left the door open for
her to participate in DAM, but we don't want to go backwards, or do old stuff,
and we are not a back-up band…. It's possible things might straighten out in
the future and that we could work together on some basis….
DAM preceded "punk music" by several years, although their
professed raison d'être was also a reaction against the pomp and circumstance
of prog rock, classic rock, the lame El Lay singer/songwriter nonsense that was
going on in the early-mid '70s. Would it be fair to say that DAM also came about
to be the antithesis of what was cluttering up the air waves [Destroy All Music,
if you will], or was it much deeper than that?
DAM was a reaction of disgust to most popular music, and an assault on the
"American Dream," but we also had things to celebrate and bring us
together¾ we drew inspiration from psychedelic
garage rock, free jazz, and the avant-garde…. There's nothing easy or simple
about DAM¾ it was (and still is) a complex art
collective. Music was part of our expression, but so was painting, collage,
film, theater, 'zines, etc…. Each of us brought a unique outlook and these
obsessions came together in sort of a massive attack that looks like anarchy,
but is really a tuned collage of fine elements. Early performances were pure
noise-fests: feedback fuzz drones, squealing amplified toys, screaming, tape
loop distortions, bashing metal and drums, etc., but things could get equally
soft and quiet¾ we'd go into dreary acoustic
goth-folk songs, and extended chord-organ tones.... We played with a lot of
traditional structure but just tore it apart. There was some political
commentary and an ironic "black humorist" approach¾
some of this grew out of our leftist leanings and sympathies with the White
Panther Party, which was already demolished. I think the WPP and Rainbow Peoples
Party were important influences. Their use of multi-colored inks and papers for
flyers and newsletters (Ann Arbor Sun/Fifth Estate) and the
psychedelic designs of artist Gary Grimshaw were beautiful, bold inspirations.
Were you aware of other scenes or artists around the country that you felt a
kinship with in the sense that you were all trying to overthrow the musical
establishment (whether it be CBGBs in NY or The Whiskey in LA or other small
venues around the country)?
I was not aware of anything happening musically like us¾
but there were pockets of interesting things happening¾
such as the LAFMS in L.A., and the Spastic Nihilism Band from Canada, but we
found out about them later. We had little interest in the punk/CBGB scene¾
it was boring. I went to CBGBs once and it was just a brawling filthy bar.
Detroit had an even crazier version called Bookies club. The Whiskey in L.A. was
an awful boogie bar in the '70s, but I did see Roky Erikson there...an amazing
show. Punk rock was mostly uncreative drivil. It was all about fashion: saftey
pins and leather. We grew up with the MC5 and the Stooges¾
that was the real shit.
I drifted into the mail-art movement in the '70s¾ passing xeroxed-art and 'zines through the mail¾ that was my first awareness and participation with contemporary art. It was an active scene¾ a distribution of art outside gallery walls, [but] it got too large, too quickly, and most people eventually dropped out. I kept a Detroit P.O. Box for Black Hole Records and did weekly mailings¾ the network was happening and that led to an exchange with Ray Johnson, an artist I felt a strong kinship for.
Do you believe that a band requires an audience in order to justify its
existence? Is there any point to making music "for yourselves,"
because isn't that essentially preaching to the choir? I think a band needs an
audience to provide feedback.
I think live performance and audience "feedback" is overrated. For
the performer it usually comes down to being a quick ego massage¾
the rush of approval¾ and that can be OK for most
musicians. There are many reasons I don't enjoy live performance, but the main
problem is, as a mode of communication, it seems unnecessary. It's a social need
that's fits inside a tribal or ritualistic setting but doesn’t hold my
interest.
Contemporary band performance embodies social skills I don't care too much about. I don't mean that we should all work in a total vacuum and never perform live. Duchamp once said "the audience completes the painting"¾ this is also true with music¾ but with recordings made easily available, the need for a sound artist to perform live puts him in competition with "entertainment" and that just becomes the need or obligation to sell a product. When the artist/musician produces mainly for the audience he's negating himself¾ he's putting food on the table and is selling the music as a commercial. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, its just not a primary interest.
Audience response is gratifying, but at the same time it's a superficial reason for making art. There should be just the necessity of making it. Music is a language that's always in the now, and being in the moment of doing it, in producing this "creative act" is really about engaging the imagination. Few live music performances outside of jazz contain that element of immediate creation. It's mostly dead air being regurgatated. Most imaginative thinking can be done in one's head. The mind makes it real. There are probably millions of unseen, unheard masterpieces…this doesn't mean they don't exist¾ and maybe in time they'll be brought into light.
One problem with popular music, is that the sound is always secondary to sales. Rock concerts are basically adolescent mating rituals. They serve the same purpose as pickup bars, and weenie roasts. It pools the youth together, socializes the audience, and breeds good consumers. Most music tends to feed into that system, it becomes a commercial to sell the audience on themselves; feeling good, sexy, or fashionable. It lacks any spiritual space or dimension. The chewy nugget center is missing.
It used to take years before a work of art filtered down and became accepted. Now it takes five minutes. Music is consumed like soda pop, and there's an audience for everything. Good art or music shouldn't have any social purpose.
Then who was the intended audience for DAMs musical outpourings?
We played for ourselves. Our early audiences were very small¾
and did nothing but encourage us to stop playing. We would often play
"guerrilla style" and just show up at a party and say we were the band¾
we were always shut down and asked to leave. We often discussed our
problem of audience reaction¾ and their basic hatred
of us¾ but we kept recording and documenting
ourselves despite that. There was a handfull of people that heard us, and
supported what we did, but it was miniscule. I guess one reason we fell apart
was that lack of support and the difficulty in distributing our work then.
It took us 25 years to find an audience; and it's still a very slim one…. I'm not sure I really know this audience, but they are probably the same marginalized folks that we were back then. Maybe there's a certain schizoid section of the public that relates to it.
What were you trying to do¾ what kind of reaction
were you anticipating from your audience?
I'm not sure we knew exactly what we were doing. First, there was no audience¾
we just did our thing like Van Gogh coughed¾ we
practised our mad-science for ourselves. I don't think our intention was to
shock, but I think that's how it was received. We wanted people to really LISTEN…to
open their heads…to witness something apocolyptic or earth-shaking…. Few
people could put up with us for long¾ the ones that
did were mostly jazz players and fellow art-students.
A lot of your material seems to be more "performance art" as
opposed to "straight" music¾ it's not
simply a static listening experience that you're looking for. DAM seems to be a
participatory experience, almost like a party atmosphere, and that your best
vehicle for getting your ideas across is in the live setting.
Everything on the 3xCD set happened live¾ mainly
in Mike's basement studio at God's Oasis, sometimes in Jim's bedroom or on the
main floor…. Just a few in-concert pieces are on it, most tracks are excerpts
from longer pieces¾ we'd usually play for ½ hour or
so and then self-critique it…. I don't see us as a "live party band"
unless it was the party onboard a UFO…. Our live shows are either amazing or
total duds….
A lot of the "songs" seem to be poetry with a musical backing¾
the vocals are more like recitations than "singing." Is this in
keeping with your desire to instruct and educate as opposed to entertain a
listener?
Niagara, Mike and I just have terrible, monotone voices... it's all God gave
us. Jim has a terrific voice, but he rarely sang back then. I never thought of
the songs as "instructive," but I like the idea. John Sinclair's
'Blues Scholar' stuff is what I'd call instructive¾
a history lesson about the blues: he does an amazing job with that…. We did
reference some historic events and moments in pop culture, but I don't think the
intention was explicit. But I am getting more into narratives in recent work.
Tell us some of the influences that were bubbling around in your head when
you were formulating the idea for DAM. A lot of it seems inspired by
improvisational/political troupes like The Committee. Could DAM be fairly
described as a vaudeville act, or an "anti-rock" band?
I had just come to Ann Arbor after a brief stay with [underground filmmaker]
Jack Smith over the summer in New York City. Jack was probably the largest
influence for me. I was interested in making a midnight theater and happening
events in our loft. These were crazy trash versions of heaven and hell plays.
We'd plaster Ann Arbor with announcement posters for these events…. [Back]
then, Mike and Jim were doing fake posters for happenings that didn't happen, so
it was perfect that we would join forces and conspire together.
Musically we were into various oddities: Yma Sumac, Martin Denny, MC5, Stooges, Nico, psychedelic rock, garage bands, Captain Beefheart, krautrock, Varese, Reich, Terry Riley, Sun Ra, big-bands, Arthur Brown, Godz, Silver Apples, etc… DAM was interested in art history; surrealism, dadaism, symbolist poetry, beat lit, avant theater, Artaud, Mad magazine, Crowley's Magick theory, noir movies, Marilyn Monroe and monster films, Stanley Mouse, weirdo trading cards…minimalists we were not. Overthrowing the establishment wasn't as important as propagating our aesthetic.
I don't think of ourselves strictly as vaudeville or comedic¾ (although elements of that are present)¾ a lot of what we did was out of a serious commitment. I think the term "anti-rock band" correctly describes what we were about. DAM is also an "art collective" and that's closer to our identity.
In the mid-late '70s, there was a shakeup in the personnel and you brought in
Ron Ashton from The Stooges and Mike Davis from MC5. Did the dreaded
"S" word [Supergroup] ever enter into your head?
Both were heroes from my favorite groups… so it was unbelievable that we
would be playing together. It was very special to be doing music with them.
Their orientation was high-energy rock¾ and the fantasy
(playing in my head) was a combo of Detroit metal and freeform psych/noise
experimentation. I wanted to incorporate a lot of multi-media¾
sort of a Detroit version of "the exploding plastic inevitible."
I assume you remained friends with Mike and Jim over the years and you
reformed in 1995 and staged several reunion tours, captured across a half dozen
disks and EPs. What prompted everyone to give it another go after nearly 15
years?
The reunion in 1995 marked over 20 years since DAM formed¾
we had just released the 3xCD set and Kelley was coming to Detroit to give a
lecture at the [Detroit] Institute of Arts [DIA]. I had decided to re-release
the 'zines from the 70s as the Geisha This book¾
so it came together quickly. We did a couple rehearsals and it happened. We also
had an art exhibit of our archives and it was mainly just a fun thing to do. The
interest in the CD set was strong and doing a show seemed a proper celebration.
Tell us a little about your new "Swamp Gas" release? Did you get
together to record new material simply as a means to finally releasing Mike's
'Dexter 1966' rant¾ was that the springboard for the
project?
That was recorded in Detroit around 1999, with members of Monster Island,
Marnie Weber (Jim's wife), and Anneke Auer of Rotterdam also helping out. We
recorded the music long before we added Mike's text. His 2002 text was a
replacement for "'The Colors of UFOs"¾ a
piece Mike wanted to use for another project, so I was waiting for something
that would work with the space theme and music.
We discussed doing a "Swamp Gas" project as we went up north in Michigan to visit the "Shrine of the Pines"¾ a 1920s cabin full of surreal handmade furniture…. When Mike came to town for the opening of the "Artists Take On Detroit" exhibition at the DIA¾ (both Mike and DAM had art installations in the show), we recorded his text at the bookstore [Cary's Book Beat shop] and I overlaid it later with the music. I was also working on "The Map Of Eternity," an interactive collage and website project of UFO, channeling, garage rock, and psychedelic trip descriptions. Some of that were incorporated into the Swamp Gas Gazette, a UFO 'zine we put together that accompanies the CD. The eternity map is also featured as the menu and title page for Blastitude #13, a website journal I'm guest editing at www.blastitude.com.
How did you come into possession of the Sun Ra vocal track that you sample
throughout?
I've been working on a Sun Ra book and CD project for the past five years.
I've collected original recordings and interviews, and commissioned some writing
and artwork for it. Sun Ra did a week of concerts before New Year's 1980, at the
Detroit Jazz Center. They did three shows a day, and played every song in their
repertoire. John Sinclair recorded them all off the sound board and it's been
our dream to one day release all these recordings¾
probably a 10 CD set! [Another Terrascope exclusive announcement!]
There's also some material provided by Japanese "noisebrother,"
Violent Onsen Geisha. Did you meet him during your tour of Tokyo and take the
tapes back to weave into the project?
I contacted Nakahara (Violent Onsen Geisha) about a year before we went to
Japan, and we played a few dates with him in '96. I was a fan of his
noise/collage projects (and he also was into DAM). When I mentioned the
"outer-space" project DAM was doing, he agreed to send us some samples
for it¾ he ended up sending us three CDs and we just
placed them randomly throughout "Swamp Gas." I should also note that
"Swamp Gas" was a single long take, edited into separate tracks.
Was your tour of Japan an eye opener in the sense of how people still
appreciated what DAM had accomplished? Are you more popular over there than in
your own country?
Japan was a great experience. In terms of music, it's incredible how noise
and fringe rock had developed into this huge mass of support and energy. It was
mainly among young teenagers who followed this stuff. It's hard to imagine all
these kids seriously following noise bands¾ it's
such marginal and lightly covered stuff in the USA. The Boredoms were like
folk-heroes, recognized and stopped on the streets. There was this respect and
attention given to artists that would never happen over here.
DAM seemed to have a fan base and a history that was already known about in Japan. We spent one day doing nonstop interviews and reporters had an amazing knowledge of this stuff. It was always one of our dreams to play Japan, so it was a great honor to play there, (even though the main show in Tokyo was sort of a flop).
Although you've moved on to Monster Island, is DAM still an active project
and do you envision any tours, perhaps to promote "Swamp Gas"?
DAM is still an active group, it just goes into "sleep-mode" often
after a performance. We played at the "All Tomorrows Parties" festival
at UCLA in March, 2002, which was an amazing event¾
an incredible gathering of over 100 avant-garde sound groups from across the
world¾ one of the most inspiring concerts I've been
to. So once every year or two, DAM gets together and we do our noise chaos….
Since the reunion gigs in '95 we've played Osaka and Tokyo (1996), Rotterdam and
Vienna (1998), Seattle (2000), and Los Angeles (2002).
We recently had an installation of four large murals and video art in the Whitney Biennial in NYC, but getting us in a van and hitting the road is probably out of the question. We each have too many professional and family commitments, and besides we're not big fans of playing live¾ it generates a lot of anxiety. We did three reunion gigs in 1995 and were booted off stage in San Diego¾ actually we were unplugged like the old days, and there was almost a small riot.
I could see us playing special events, or doing a few more art-related things¾ mixing the performance with a new installation, or playing inside the installation. We hope to put out a reissue of the 3xCD set, and possibly a double-CD from live shows of the past six years. Mike is now editing that work.
Xanadu
You also had a shortlived offshoot, Xanadu, with the Miller brothers (Larry
& Ben) and Rob King. That material (the 'Blackout in The City' EP) had a
very Zappa & The Mothers quality to it. Another influence or just a damn
good impersonation?
The earlier DAM material seems rooted in Zappa's approach to cacophonous mind
manipulation.
That's a large leap from early DAM to Zappa! He was really an anal
perfectionist that constructed his work almost note for note (and that's not
meant necessarily as a negative thing). We'd probably be recorded on
Straight/Bizzare if we formed five years earlier. Although Zappa took a much
more traditional and rarefied approach to music, we both admired the same
avant-garde: Varese, Cage, Partch, Reich, etc., but our approach to recording
and end results were very different, almost opposite….
DAM was playing with chance happenings, psychedelia, theater, ironic humor, crackpot instruments, and lo-fi recording. I don't think the word "control" was in our vocabulary, and we could never reproduce or do the same thing twice. We made postmodern, homemade "elemental" ESP-style trance noise-rock, which was far more gritty, obscure and spontaneous than Zappa.
The overlap is probably in the tongue-in-cheek satire department and our use of parody and black-humor. However, most of the songs done under Xanadu came about through visionary experiences. The lyrics and music were composed under altered states of conciousness, even the EP sleeve design was connected to a vision.
It's interesting that you view it as Zappa-esque or "mind manipulation," I was seriously trying to deal with a mental state I was not in control of then. Music and poetry were my safety nets. [The Xanadu material] represents a very different (more dark and removed) body of work. It was the only project we did, but I really enjoyed working with Ben and Laurence¾ both sensitive, multi-talented musicians. They brought masterful playing and off-kilter ideas into Xanadu. I hope an expanded CD will show this in a better light.
Nightcrawlerz
I must confess to total ignorance about this project, and I've read some
comments that the material was pretty "self-indulgent." What exactly
were you on about there?
After hearing the retrospective, I'll never listen to another Bongwater album
in the same light or snicker at the juvenile delinquency of Beavis &
Butthead or those Mystery Science Theater videos and marvel at their
so-idiotic-it's-brilliant thesis anymore.
I recently heard Bongwater just a few years ago when Mike Kelley and Art
Byington played as Ann Magnusen's backing band in Los Angeles¾
Jim Shaw also painted and designed Ann's "Luv Show" CD. I think they
were much more connected to producing conventional music then we were.
I've rarley seen Bevis and Butthead, but Mystery Science Theater was something I dug and watched at my friend George's house almost every Saturday night. That show expressed our attitude when we watched those grade Z bombs in the '60s and '70s, and as DAM we soaked up a lot of those at God's Oasis.
In the '60s there was a TV horror-show host named Ghoulardi from Cleveland who had a shtick of making fun of all the bad movies. In early '60s Detroit, we had "Morgus The Magnificent," and The Ghoul in the '70s. Vampirella did the same thing in Los Angeles. I like the idea of commentary and farce¾ the burlesque of the real (or unreal)¾ there's a high level of parody in the works you mentioned, but as an approach and technique its nothing original. I always cite Mad magazine as being a major influence. We grew up with that beautiful, Mad-genius stuff, ¾ hilarious, mind-blowing, as psychedelic as anything in the late '60s¾ artists like Wolverton and Virgil Partch cast a long shadow on us.
Did it frustrate you to see the attention heaped on these obvious
"appropriators" of your aesthetic, and are you concerned that folks
picking up "The Third Mind" might just shrug it off as
"retro-juvenalia" and ignore it's cultural significance?
I think parody and black humor show up in all these projects. It concerns me
that this parodistic reading may be misread as the sole meaning behind Nightcrawlerz;
it's there, but not really central to our project, which I consider to be
orthodox and spiritually based. My intention in putting out "The Third
Mind" was to complete a documentation of a ten-year project that Barry Roth
and I began in the late '70s. We were concerned with meaning in poetry, poetic
invention, the sound of words¾ "projective
verse" and the raw "sound" of sounds¾
the essence of things…getting to the nucleus of matter and form, stripping
meat from the bones. Nightcrawlerz was a complex collage and
constructionist word-based project that focused on the repetition and chant of
sound and words to alter their meanings. There were many layers and different
directions explored over ten year's time. We sent hundreds of Nightcrawlerz
'zines to artists around the world¾ we tapped into
the mail-art network and did some collaborations (both audio and visual) with
Ray Johnson, an important figure in Fluxus and pop-art circles.
After DAMs implosion, were you anxious to continue with the same modus
operandi and return to what DAM was originally intended to accomplish, or was
Nightcrawlerz really nothing more than what it sounds like: a couple of friends
fooling around with a bunch of tapes, toy instruments, answering machines and
too much time on their hands trying to change the world from the comfort of
their own basement?
When I left DAM in '77, it lost most of its drive and imagination, and was
headed in the direction of punk rock¾ the popular
idiom of the time. I decided to return to photography and finish a degree at
Wayne State University in Detroit, which is where I met Barry Roth, who was an
instructor. In one sense Nightcrawlerz was a return to the innocence and
experiment of early DAM, but we were into a serious investigation into
literature. Gysin and Burroughs were a strong influence. We made collages of
poems, drawings, photos, sculptures, and sculptures of sound molded and played
with the layers; encoding with signs, Kabbalah notation, and neo-Beat jargon¾
we tried to keep the work "outside ourselves." While it dealt with
daily personal material, it had universal designs. It served as diary, story
telling, and magic offering. Nightcrawlerz' projects were clumsy organic
stews¾ the music hummed like a devotional chant.
Maybe it was an attempt to create a new monster¾ a golom
that could live and protect us. As poet-musicians, we were too stupid/naive to
make anything easy or clear, let alone "change the world." I guess the
humor sometimes eclipsed the spiritual intent, and to really change the world we
need to work on ourselves.
I understand you recorded over fifty 90 minute cassettes worth of material
and whittled it down to about 2½ hours and two disks worth of mayhem. Was the
selection process as harrowing an experience as recording the material in the
first place?
It wasn't too bad. I transferred anything that sounded interesting onto about
12 mini-discs¾ that took a couple months. Then Warn
Defever and I edited the pieces down into short sections in a few days. We saved
a few long works, but our aim was to get the statement down quickly and go on.
We let the computer randomly do the final selection and track layout.
Some of the material sounds like it was a very time-consuming affair to
assemble. I'm particularly fond of what you did on "John Lennon." [The
track¾ nothing on here could really be honored with
the appelation "song"¾ begins with
excerpts from a live newscast describing his assassination, brilliantly
incorporates Barbara Stanwyck begging "Johnny" not to die [from the
film, Meet John Doe], and then segues into some interviews with folks who
attended a Beatles concert. It's chilling the way a totally out-of-context clip
from the reaction to John Lennon "live" (in concert) is juxtaposed
with almost the exact same reaction to his death.] Your liner notes: "OK,
scary, use it, maybe Yoko will sue us! Kool!" I assume you haven't heard
from "Mrs. Lennon?"
I heard from Yoko a few years ago. She sent a small drawing with a note that
said, "I'll be seeing you on Monster Island one day." (This was after
I sent her a copy of the first Monster Island LP), but the piece about
Lennon was done from material recorded the night he died. I had a few cassettes
of these radio and TV newscasts¾ everyone commenting
on Lennon's life and death. I just couldn't get away from it and recorded
everything¾ it was really made out of shock or
disbelief…. The film Meet John Doe was also playing that night, and it
seemed to fit into the surrealness of it. Lennon's death was a heavy trip, and
it was a way to work through it. The editing on most of "The Third
Mind" is pretty straightforward¾ we just tried
to cut out a lot of repetition. Everything was assembled with multiple tape
recorders, playing along with us live. Our major technique was splicing
tape-loops into repetitve poems or soundscapes.
Did Nightcrawlerz just peter out, or did you and Barry get bored with all the
work involved in assembling these sound collages with limited financial return
on investment?
Barry had a family to raise and I was trying to get the bookstore afloat¾
responsibilities kept creeping in and made it difficult to continue. We also
said what we wanted. Just recently we held a small retrospective of our artwork.
We've remained close friends and are collaborating on some new sculptural
pieces. It's hard to say if we'd go back to recording. There may be an
opportunity to produce a Nightcrawlerz theater piece in the future¾
that's a direction I've always wanted to take. It would open the process up, and
I think our sketches and routines would work well in 3-dimensions¾
dance or dramatic presentation.
Monster Island
Sitars, tambourines, ouds, violins, harmoniums, Chinese organs, acoustic
guitars, etc. converge behind simple sing-song melodies that have fairy
tale/nursery-rhyme qualities about them¾ it all
comes across like Hapshash meets The Fool. I can imagine the freaks in Golden
Gate Park dancing frivously around the Panhandle at some "gathering of the
tribes" reunion with this blaring from every beatbox within earshot
celebrating the 35th anniversary of the Summer of Love. Based on your
previous [track]records and what seems to be a disdain for straightforward song
structures, what ever possessed you to start a project like this?
This also seems like the second "supergroup" you’ve been involved
with—this time with some of the major players of the Detroit alternative
scene?
I think of Monster Island more as an "anti-supergroup"¾
no flash or talent showoffs, just friends getting together and slowing down....
My hope is we can transcend some of the trappings of our past and individual
identities. I always liked Godzuki [Erika Hoffman], Outrageous Cherry [Matt
Smith], and His Name Is Alive [Warn Defevre]¾ they
were/are some of the more creative bands in Detroit. It's always a special
natural thing when we get together, and it gives us a chance to try out
something different.
You don't so much sing the lyrics as recite them. In this respect, are the
songs more like poetry set to music, and is that MIs preferred modus operandi?
I have a monotonal voice with no range, so I try to get other people to do
vocals when I can. I'm getting into storytelling with sound¾
"Peyote Mind" [see below] and "Fantomas" are examples [the
band recently completed the DVD soundtrack for the re-edited version of
"Fantomas" (entitled "Fantomash"), which was presented at
the Boijman Museum in Amsterdam in October]—it’s like adding a document into
song...putting another layer on top. I think Erika interprets the songs well¾
her voice is child-like and lyrical, so there's a strange balance between
singing and recitation.
The communal vibe around these releases reminds me also of early krautrockers
Amon Düül and the ethnic world/folk of Atman/Magic Carpathians and Japanese
folk/psych band Ghost. Do you regularly "test the waters" to see what
types of music are out there that might benefit from the Cary Loren Treatment¾
great name for a band, that!
Thanks, that's great company¾ I was familiar with
Amon Düül, Can, and Kraftwerk in the early ‘70s, and Atman and Ghost in the
mid-‘90s. [As Cary mentioned earlier, the members of what was to become Monster
Island initially met at a Ghost concert!] Also, Erica Pomerance's late ‘60s
ESP freakout disk was a real revelation. I loved Vivaldi's chamber music and
Ginsberg's treatment of Blake's poems as a teenager, so everything you
experience is probably assimilated somehow…. But I don't approach music as
subject for a certain style or "treatment." It must have meaning
first. The truth of the moment is an important practice. This gets reinforced
when you perform with people focused on the same ideas. Monster Island is
basically an acoustic "low volume" band¾
the approach to improv relates well with free-jazz and junkyard "folk"
creation.
Communal bands sometimes have this tight and responsive nature that's a reflection of love or energy within the group. Shared ideals and backgrounds work together. All bands in a sense are communal¾ you get together to produce something. Music is one of the most social, yet anti-capitalist artforms and there lies its beauty: it's untouchable, in the air and free.
The name Monster Island conveys a sense of both unity and isolation¾ the various ethnic rhythms and instruments of African, Chinese, Indonesian, Indian, and Haitian music would identify us as a world music bastard. I've always liked the idea of islands¾ the flowery exoticness, isolation and genetic creativity. The island where all monsters are allowed to exist in peace seemed idyllic. The name also links us back to the motherband [DAM].
Was there a lot of backlash from people who didn't realize that 'Hiroshima
Bop' was an antiwar song and not a tribal dance celebrating politically
sanctioned murder, whether it be at Dachau, Hiroshima, Kent St., Sarajevo, etc.
That was a song DAM did in rehearsals before we went to Japan. I thought it
would be a good antiwar song to do¾ "looking at
the fire thru the eyes of the dead." It was written for the 50th
anniversary of the bombing of Hiroshima, but no one wanted to do it¾
they thought the Japanese would misunderstand it so it was dropped. I like doing
that, as it always ends in a big percussion freakout. I was trying to link all
these atrocities together¾ we have a great capacity
for destroying ourselves in new and surprising ways.
"Confessions" sounds like Lou Reed leading a Hari Krishna marching
band with shakahachi, bells, etc. clattering around in the background. Yet this
particular track was dedicated to Sonic Youth. Tell us about the connection with
SY, particularly with that song?
It's about the life of Antonio Gaudi: "killed by a streetcar your work
left undone"…"Islamic mosaics, pulsing hypnotic"..."walls
bejeweled, and windows elliptic." He was a Catalan architect who was run
over by a streetcar and never saw his major masterpiece, the Salgrada cathedral,
built: "Barcelona in shadows that crumble and die…." It’s a
massive structure still under construction today¾
one of the most dazzling, organic, neo-baroque buildings.
Another theme in 'Confessions' is the Spanish Inquisition: "the torturer, he is your lover too…," which came out of the Garcia-Marquez novel, Of Love And Other Demons and the book Poison by Kathryn Harrison. Both song and books explore relationships between authority: priests/executioners and the sexual attractions to their victims and their forbidden lusts: "opening your flesh and seeking the truth…."
The underpinnings of "catholic guilt"¾ body/mind/soul conflicts and commentary on social hypocrisy also are rampant in Sonic Youth¾ it's a recurrent theme they explore. There's also the unfinished/raw soundscapes SY bring to their music¾ a kind of baroque form of rock 'n' roll which reminded me of Gaudi's catholic structures: odd angles, psychedelic and sensuous textures…. Actually, I gotta fess up: I stole a few chord progressions and odd tunings from a SY song¾ 'Cotton Crown' I think¾ I saw it in one of those Guitar Player articles¾ a totally shameless rip-off...so I thought 'Confession for Sonic Youth' could also be read in a literal sense… The song was also covered by DAM on our "Silver Wedding Anniversary" album.
You're obviously a voracious reader. A lot of literary references appear
throughout your various projects, from the obvious (Gysin, Burroughs,
Appolonaire, Tennyson) to the implied (Artaud, Lautremont, the existentialists
like Camus and Sartre, and the Soviet anarchists), and you also run The Book
Beat shop. Tell us how you became involved with that?
The Book Beat opened in 1982¾ I was unprepared to
make a living doing anything else. I collected and sold books while in school.
In the fine-arts field you either go into teaching, or try and market yourself.
Neither looked promising to me. Bookselling was something one can do while still
being somewhat antisocial. It became a successful venture despite my lack of
business sense and now helps to support some of these projects.
Tell us about The Gallery. You've put on shows here, but I'm not too sure
what the whole concept is about.
The Book Beat Gallery began soon after we opened. I show artwork that
intrigues me or that I find interesting. Mainly photography and folk-art. I'm
not really a "galleriest"¾ marketing and
sales are not the point. I have a small space and try to launch creative
exhibits onto an unsuspecting public. It helps to keep me stimulated¾
the gallery is an education and connects us to the community¾
Detroit can be a bleak space, and this is one of the saner areas.
Throughout your career, your material also has many references to modern
culture, particularly in the realm of science fiction: Dr. Phibes, Mothra [the
title of a song on MIs second album, "Dream Tiger"], Godzilla, et. al.
Is that just a genre you find ripe for inspiration or material, or do you think
there's more to SF than meets the eye…adhering, perhaps, to the preferred
translation of "S.F." as "speculative fiction"?
I'm not a big reader of SF, but am a fan of monster movies and monster movie
soundtracks¾ I guess it's stuff I grew up with and
still find fascinating. There are parallels to how we as a society view and
picture monsters and how we reflect our fears and phobias onto the face of them.
Space aliens with mutated bodies, giant heads, lagoon creatures, zombies, and
oozing blob liquids were prominent in the '50s at a time we were [also]
hyper-conscious of sexuality, car fins, and the godliness=cleanliness=USA
virtues, so our monsters were these sick gross concoctions, projections of our
fears. Then the hi-tech robotic/bionic transformer Robocop look of the '80s
escalated with the dominance of computer technology. We kind of sublimate our
fears and anxieties and project them onto the movie screen. I also love the
soundtracks in monster flicks¾ it's usually the most
extreme experimental music. In DAM, we used to play along with some of these
movies, mixing the movie background noise with our own.
Both of your previous projects gave rise to accompanying fanzines: six issues
of Destroy All Monsters magazine and eight issues of the Nightcrawlerz'
zine. Any chance a Monster Island 'zine is in the offing?
Tell us a bit about the "Peyote Mind" collaboration with John
Sinclair? It seems like a match made in hell¾
marrying your collective political agendas to the avant, freeform jazz sounds
that were instrumental to the overall DAM aesthetic.
It's so different from the "regular" MI releases, I wonder where
you see that project heading. Do you intend on continuing in the wyrdfolk
direction on studio releases, but break into avant skronk whenever you hit the
stage?
I really don't know where it's headed. I'd like to do a couple more
"song" albums, but it might all fall apart and go somewhere else.
Playing our songs live is difficult. You need an attentive, quiet audience to
pull it off, which is rare to find in Detroit, so we usually opt for the
freeform improv [which the band performed with poet Ira Cohen in December].
We thank Cary for his honesty and willingness to share his musical history and personal demons with us. For additional information, please visit Cary's site, or drop him a line. Tell him the Terrascope sent you.