My take on the "McLain Problem".  I first encountered this little hiccup on Rebecca's Genealogies of the XI Kingdoms.  To me it's simply errata and can be fixed by correcting Morgan's misstatement in The Bishop's Heir.

Morgan's pesky misstatement:

"Neither Duncan's father or his grandfather had any brothers, but his grandfather had two
sisters. The younger, my paternal grandmother, produced one son, my father. The elder
sister also produced a son, however; and he married the Princess Annalind of Meara."
Hardbound: page 39   Paper: page 41

As it turns out, Morgan doesn't know his family history as well as he thinks he does.  Review this chart:

The corrected statement should read:

"Neither Duncan's father or his grandfather had any brothers, but his great-grandfather had two
sisters. The younger, my paternal grandmother, produced one son, my father. The elder
sister  had a daughter, however; and she married the Princess Annalind of Meara's son*."

In less colorful terms:  Neither Duncan's father (Jared McLain) or his grandfather (Andrew McLain) had any brothers, but his great-grandfather (Tairchell McLain) had two sisters.  The younger, my paternal grandmother (Madonna McLain), produced one son, my father (Kenneth Morgan).  The elder sister [? McLain (Fergus MacFaolan's second wife)] had a daughter (Aude MacFaolan), however, and she married the Princess Annalind of Meara's son (Judael Quinnell-Kincaid)."

Note: It could be said that the MacFaolan's have a claim on the succession of Duncan's Cassan and Kierney titles unless Colman MacFaolan is the product of Fergus MacFaolan's first marriage.  Since this question isn't yet answered, there is no way to know.  But I suspect that the MacFaolan's aren't in the succession because that would make a major point of The Bishop's Heir and The King's Justice moot since the novels  are as much about the succession of Cassan and Kierney as they are about the bid for Mearan independence.



All the above information comes from the descendent charts I made based on information found in the following sources:
Rebecca Davis's Genealogies of the XI Kingdoms
The text of King Kelson's Bride
The appendix of King Kelson's Bride
Various email messages from Rebecca Davis and others
alt.books.deryni

Home | Email  | Glossary  | Castle  | Jewelry  | Horses  | Church  | Monastary Map  | Vestments  | Armor  | Weapon  | Cousins  |  Descendents of Saint Camber  | Morgans  | Haldane Men and Children  | Haldane Women  | McLains | Other Prominent People | Errata and Inconsistencies  | Heraldic |