 |
Giuliano, Stearns
and Palmieri in La Traviata |
Post critic: a Traviata that brings
out 'the full musical and dramatic value in Verdi's brilliant score'
Bel Canto's 'Traviata':
There's Less, There's More
By Joseph McLellan, November 18, 2003
The Opera Bel Canto production of La Traviata given Sunday
at Mount Vernon Place United Methodist Church was nowhere near as
glittery and elaborate as the one the Washington Opera will produce
later this season. But this performance with a small chamber orchestra
was well worth attending. Among other points, it was probably the
first truly complete performance ever given in the Washington area,
restoring a number of passages that are usually omitted, including
a substantial aria for the elder Germont.
A note in the program argues that La Traviata should
be recognized as "the last bel canto opera," with its
"soaring melodies" and "dazzling cadenzas."
True enough, but it could also be called the first verismo opera,
with its contemporary setting and its doomed, tubercular, demimondaine
heroine.
This performance showed that it is both. The performance subtly
emphasized the bel canto elements, particularly in the often richly
ornamented singing of Marje Palmieri (Violetta), who had the finest
voice in the cast and used it with intelligence and expressive power.
Also vocally outstanding was baritone Jason Stearns as Giorgio Germont.
His long scena with Palmieri in Act 2 was one of the musical highlights
of the performance.
Tenor Antonio Giuliano was generally good as his impetuous son
Alfredo, though his voice sometimes had a metallic edge and some
of his high notes were ambiguous in intonation. Abigail Endicott
began a bit tentatively in the role of the maid Annina, but quickly
established a strong vocal and theatrical presence. Six small supporting
roles were well filled, the chorus was outstanding, and conductor
Micaele Sparacino brought out the full musical and dramatic value
in Verdi's brilliant score.
There will be a repeat performance Sunday.
|