QUICK SUGGESTIONS FOR BIKE BUYING

Last Updated: 09/08/2006

UNDER CONSTRUCTION


OVERVIEW

The heart and soul of a bike is the frame. And when chosing a road frame one should consider the 3 F's:
  • Fit
  • Function and
  • Fashion
  • MENU


    Fit: is the most obvious thing, especially when your fit is wrong. Bad fit makes your body hurt and undermines your performance. But getting a good fit is hard and can literally take years. Much has been written on the subject of bike fit and I will not attempt to give specific advice. Instead, I will offer 4 generalities.

    First, understand that there are different styles of fit. The best advice on this subject that I've seen is the essay "The Traditions of Road Riding and Our Three Styles of Fit" at the Competitive Cyclist website, which defines 3 different styles of fit: a low handle bar competitive fit, a more sensible "Merckx" fit and a touring oriented fit. Second, once you understand the different fitting styles, use their Fit Calculator to determine your frame size and buy a frame based on their formula driven suggestions. Thirdly, fine tune the fit by changing components such as the handlebar stem. The best article I've read on adjusting your fit is by Peter White at his website. Fourth and finally, seek good bike shops that offer fitting services, but don't let ex-racers steer you toward a low-bar racing type of fit.

    I go into more detail on these fitting issues on my Frame Fitting Web Page.

    Return to Top


    Function: is determined by the frame's geometry and a handful of other design features. The most common geometry is the Road Racer. They are fast, responsive and a lot fun. But, compared to other bike designs they can also seem harsh, twitchy and punishing on longer rides.

    I think there are 4 other bike designs that bears mentioning. Touring bikes are stable and strongly built (read: sluggish and heavy) to withstand the rigors of carrying a full load over a variety of surfaces. In between these 2 extremes are the Club Racer (or Audax) bikes and the Sport Touring bikes. These bikes have the same light weight construction as racing bikes, but are more stable and comfortable on long rides. Sport Touring bikes differ from Audax type bikes in that they can be used with panniers. The last road bike design to mention is arguably not a road bike and that is the Cyclocross bike. Cross bikes pre-date mountain bikes by decades but have only been gathering popularity in North America in recent years. Picture a road bike with knobbie tires and you'll get the basic idea.

    Personally, I'm a huge fan of the Sport Touring design. I go into more detail on frame geometries on my Frame Geometries Web Page.

    There are several other design features that have a big impact on how well a bike frame is suited to your intended purposes. Some frames will not accept moderate width tires, much less wider tires, thus limiting their use. Frames are generally built to accept a certain style or size of brake. And different uses require fenders or racks, both of which need special fittings.

    I go into more detail on these features on my Bike Frame Design Web Page.

    Return to Top


    Fashion: is the 3rd and final consideration and just might be the most important in terms of choosing a bike you will use and love for years or even decades. Fashion is often dismissed as a triviality, but at it's core it is how we choose to reflect who are we are to the rest of the world. I'm very convinced that 99% of bike choices are primarily driven by our need to say something about ourselves - that is, by our need to make a fashion statement.

    I think there are 4 different primary styles of bike to consider. The first is the New Ultimate. As of this writing, the New Ultimate is carbon fiber but this has a tendancy to change every few years. So, if you want the New Ultimate, be prepared to buy new again in a few years. The second style is welded (or glued) metal. The type of metal could be steel, titanium or, most likely, some type of aluminum. These bikes have a clean, modern look. The third style is lugged steel. This is the style associated with older classic bikes, but this style is still currently produced. The lug styles range from clean and simple to very orante. And lastly, there is what I call the "Beater Chic" style. These are bikes that look like abused beaters but are actually top quality bikes.

    I go into more detail on these styles on my Bike Styles Web Page.

    Return to Top


    Dave's Backcountry Skiing Page
    Dave's Cycling Page

    Copyright 2006 by David Mann