| 4500+ Great Links | Hands-On Review of the Sciphone i68/i68+ GSM Phones | This is Caveat.tk |
| Copyright © 2008-2009 by Zack Smith. All rights reserved. See also my general overview of the Sciphone i68 and i68+ phones. DisclaimerThe information on this web page is provided AS-IS. Use it at your own risk. I cannot guarantee that it is 100% accurate, for two reasons.1. Chinese phones such as those bearing the generic brand Sciphone, Miphone, Ciphone, Hiphone or CECT can vary substantially in the hardware and software provided. For example, it is known that there are 60+ hardware variants of the Sciphone i68/i68+. 2. I have owned the Sciphone i68, i68+, and the CECT M88 and M89, and played with another person's P168, but not the 100 or more other types of Asian GSM phones in existence. 3. I am not affiliated with the manufacturers of these and cannot provide any support or personal advising. Buying and using an Asian phone involves accepting some risk. In my humble opinion, the payoffs are worth it, since these phones are cheap, they work with prepaid SIMs, and they have lots of features. Introduction
I originally did this review for a generic i68 with generic pre-3.0 firmware. Since then I've gotten an i68+ with version 3.1 firmware, so I've tried to update the review to point out the differences between the two where they arise. In addition, Javquisoft 4.0 firmware was rolled out and I upgraded my phone to that, which allowed some customizations. Contents
Features
Storage
Multimedia
Programs
Communicating
Hardware
Other
FeaturesThe following applies to both the i68 and i68+:
Flash memory cardsThe phone accepts one MicroSD flash card, reportedly up to 8 gigaytes. I've used two different ones in my phone:
Transferring files to the phoneThe i68/i68+ are media-centric cell phones. As such you will probably want to transfer media files to it and the procedure for doing so is very simple:
DirectoriesThe directories (folders) on the MicroSD flash card are as follows:
Music PlayerThe phone comes with a decent but very basic music player program. I have experimentally determined that the generic i68 firmware can play the following types of music files:
The version 3.0a software handled MP3 and WAV but I did not test others. What kinds of MP3s work best?Bass is not great on the speakers, and yet bass guitar sounds passable with the headphones. I converted this bass player video and it sounds almost as good as on my PC.Pop music should be mostly OK with headphones and sometimes with speakers. Flamenco sounds better on the speakers than headphones, because the guitar is high-pitched anyway. The headphones make it sound blurred or muddled, although it may help to turn on the equalizer and set it to Treble. Podcasts such as Truth About Markets sound much better with headphones. How is the audio quality?SpeakersThe sound quality produced on the built-in small speakers is good and loud, but rather tinny i.e. lacking in bass. Using test files at swing.be I got the following results:
Headphones with adapterThere is an optional adapter that lets you use your own headphones. I have this adapter and the sound quality is good enough for me. But of course, how well it works for you depends on how good your headphones are. I am only using $8 headphones.
EarbudsThe earbuds that I recieved with the i68+ are just OK quality. They are better than the speakers but they just don't compare to the adapter with my cheap headphones.At the same volume level as my headphone tests, I got:
Problems
What free programs exist to edit music files and rip CDs?For ripping, use CDex or FreeRIP.To edit audio, try Audacity or WavePad. Video PlayerThis phone does play videos. You can load them onto the MicroSD or into the internal memory in the same way you do MP3 files except that you must put them in the Video directory.Supported video formatsAs with other mobile phones, the video player program does not play just any video file format. At this point I have managed to get small 3GP, 3G2 and MP4 videos to play with the version 3.1 firmware's player. The generic firmware's player didn't accept 3G2.
Note that 3GP, 3G2 and MP4 are just containers. The codec that is used to compress the movie can be
After much experimentation, 176x144 remains the largest resolution that has worked for me. Anything larger than that is rejected. Here are a few sample videos:
Converting videosI encode videos using FFMPEG, which is an open source video converter that can be used either from the DOS prompt (the command line) or using a GUI. The best GUI for FFMPEG seems to be WinFF. Make sure you download it from this link and not another.In WinFF, these settings worked best for the 3.1 firmware and Javquisoft 4.0 firmware:
These settings worked best with the generic firmware:
Give it a try using this animation of a rotating 60-carbon "buckyball". Editing videosIf you want to edit a video for any reason, for instance to remove a sequence or to create your own movie, there are basically two free options.Playback qualityThe generic firmware was not great at playing videos and tended to drop a lot of frames, providing 5 to 8 frames per second.Things have improved due to Javquisoft's update and it is somewhat smoother, with a maximum more like 15 fps. Regardless of which firmware your phone has, note that video quality is dependent on how well the video was encoded, which depends on:
Regarding video size, the only way to achieve a video larger than 176x144 is to create an animated GIF, which of course has no sound. See here. OrientationThe video player program responds to the orientation of the phone. If you hold it in upright (portrait) mode, you get a smallish, narrow image like on a TV. If you rotate the phone 90 degrees you get landscape mode: Videos appear larger but any widescreen video will look much nicer.What kinds of videos are worth converting?Many kinds of videos are not suitable for a small screen such as the i68/i68+'s, or a low frame rate. I find that cartoons, animations, and interviews work best. For instance, TV interviews look good. Videos that fill the frame with a person's head or body are best.Also, videos with a lot of action or where the camera is handheld fare worse because they are harder for the codec to compress and for the phone to decompress, so movement may appear jumpy. How large are the files?
Photo ViewerThe photo viewer included with the version 3 firmware includes touch-flow behavior.The generic firmware's viewer that I used previously was quite clunky and required clicking a small button to go to the next image. To use the viewer, you select a photo from a list, then select View and it appears. Using the touch-flow feature you just slide your finger across the touch screen leftward or rightward to go to the next or previous image, respectively. Touch-flow also allows you to zoom in or out by moving your finger up or down the screen. While viewing a photo, if you rotate the phone to landscape mode the photo will rotate as well. You can also browse thumbnails, which appear somewhat slowly. Image file formatsI have experimentally determined that the generic, pre-3.0a firmware's viewer that I had before I got the i68+ with its 3.1 firmware, supported the following image formats:
Meanwhile, the viewer provided by version 3.1 firmware is mostly the same in terms of image file format support, with two differences:
What about animated GIFs?These work. In fact, they are the basis for a lot of the simple animations used in the phone, like the opening "Sciphone" logo. You could call them an alternative to videos except, needless to say, they have no sound. Animated GIFs are advantageous because you can use them for higher-resolution videos, albeit at maybe 2 or 3 frames per second. In addition, GIFs are limited to 256 colors. You view them in the Photo Viewer, not the Video Player.Using the viewer in the generic firmware, the maximum frame rate for animated GIFs appeared to be slightly worse than Xvids at the same resolution. I created one that was 320x240 using SUPER.
I no longer use SUPER because McAfee detected malware
in one of its codecs.
I now use
WinFF.
Using the version 3.1 firmware, animated GIFs look poor in comparison to the 10+ frames per second of the video player. Try this video to see what I mean. GIFs of the collapse of World Trade Center building #7 on 9/11This is an interesting GIF version of a popular video. WTC7 was a high-security building used by the CIA and the mayor's emergency office. It also contained the records of Wall Street investigations, e.g. into Enron. It was not hit by any plane nor by major debris nor did it have significant fires. Its collapse was unequivocably a controlled demolition. Yet the US government has stalled the investigation of WTC7's collapse for years. Samples of WTC dust however (collected before the WTC7 collapse) show the ubiquitous presence of unexploded thermate particles. Thermate is an explosive the patent for which is owned by the US military. More info.Here is a grayscale 240x176 animation, perhaps 4 frames/second:
Here is a simple color 200x150, 6 fps, 64-color animation:
Click here for a 176x144 video at 12 fps equivalent to the above. How to make a good animated GIF
Problems
CameraThe built-in camera is essentially just a webcam. It could never substitute for a real camera. It is not easy to take a decent photo with this camera.Major issues are:
Sample photosHere are a few.
Take special notice of the thin diagonal lines near the parking structure's rails. They're jagged or craggy. They are, I think, indicative that the photo is in fact interpolated, meaning it appears to be a lower-resolution image that the software increased in resolution. Now, look at the same photo below reduced to 320x240:
Notice, no jaggy lines. It is closer to the original. Here are some more 640x480 photos. Each is oddly fuzzy, suggesting to me interpolation from a 320x240 image. Click to enlarge.
Here is a more recent 640x480 that I took with the i68+ phone
in greyscale mode.
I haven't enhanced the photo except to rotate it using
the GIMP.
Click to enlarge.
Is a better camera possible in a cheap phone?Yes, definitely. Several cheap phones have appeared in Asia having high-megapixel cameras.
These phones are usually only dual-band 900/1800 MHz, so useless in North America. Video RecorderThe video recorder does a fairly terrible job. In rare situations however it may be sufficient. If you witness a police beating, for example, and this phone is all you have then by all means use it.I made a movie file which is here in edited form that is:
Audio RecorderThis appears to work fine. It stores the audio as an "amr" file, which Quicktime can read. The audio quality is just the minimum.JavaWhat files do I need?For any Java midlet that you want to run, you should download both the JAR and JAD files. The JAD describes the JAR. The JAR is the program itself. However often just the JAR itself will run without the JAD.How do I install Java programs?You copy them to the "java" directory on your MicroSD card. Then go to the main phone menu and select Documents, then java. Click on JAD file and you will be prompted as to whether to install the program. It will also ask whether you want to run it.Where do I get Java programs?It's somewhat hard to find decent Java programs to run on any phone. You can find some at:
JargonTerms that are good to know:
JAR = Java archive file.
SpeedJava works -- sometimes fast, sometimes slowly. In my experience, whether a program is fast or slow depends on how much attention the programmer(s) paid to execution speed and to the resource limitations of running on a mobile phone.For my own Java programs, which are here, I've found that putting a little extra thought and effort into making a program fast and frugal can pay off. But other programmers might decide not to bother. Why are there so few good Java programs?It turns out there are reasons for the lack of good programs. The main one is that wireless companies and resellers are very greedy. They take 75% of the selling price of any Java midlet sold through them. As a result there is very little financial incentive for programmers to write Java programs for mobile phones.Many people have labored away at writing Java programs for phones anyway, hence the large number available at getjar. But many programmers or companies who were seeking a profit have given up and moved to the Apple iPhoneTM. Some people who seek to write and distribute free programs have continued with J2ME. Consider:
Program load times
Scrolling problemMany Java programs that are not very graphical use a provided set of buttons and other widgets to build their user-interfaces. These are known as the Form object class. Programs that use Form often just assume that the phone firmware somehow implements scrolling. At present the 3.1 firmware and even Javquisoft's 4.0 firmware do not.
The Java documentation from Sun (who makes Java) does state
here
that it is the responsibility of firmware developers to implement scrolling.
It says:
Until that is implemented, Sciphone users will have to avoid Form-based midlets that use more than one screenful of information. Support for special phone featuresIt is known that the current Java support does not give Java programs access to special features like the motion/orientation sensor (gSensor).Heap size
Where to find wallpapers?I've dedicated a page to this topic:
eBook ReaderThe built-in eBook reader is only for reading text files. Depending on which version of the firmware your phone has, it may be useless or functional:The version 3.1 firmware's reader is OK, not great:
The generic firmware's eBook reader as I experienced it was junk. Your mileage may vary.
Image-based eBooksYou aren't completely stuck with the built-in reader. I produced two PNG image-based eBooks that you can read using the photo viewer:
I created these using LaTeX, dvipng and ImageMagick.
To help you make your own eBooks,
I've included my shell script ( Other image-based informationI created a 320x240 pixel version of the Periodic Table of Elements, available here:Making callsI almost forgot: It's a phone too. Getting that to work was a no-brainer.
Setting up data servicesYou need to do a Device Over The Air Configuration (DOTAC).
Text messaging / SMSData entry is an area where the pre-3.0a firmware is very hard to use. The new firmware makes it much easier to use one finger to enter a sequence of letters with minimal mistakes.On-screen keyboardThe engineer(s) who created the pre-3.0a software did not manage to replicate the facile keyboard entry of the Apple iPhone. The letters are smaller and for me, they require using the stylus. There is no auto-complete feature.The version 3.1 firmware improves the on-screen keyboard quite a bit. At this time, I do not know whether a bluetooth keyboard works with this phone. If you have one and can test it out, please let me know what the result is. Handwriting recognitionThe phone comes with built-in handwriting recognition that does a decent job of making sense of single letters. Using it is slower than using the on-screen keyboard however. And there is no way to draw a space character.BlueToothHeadsetsThese work. People have generally reported that they do but I have verified it using a Motorola H500 ear-piece type of headset. The Sciphone menus were a little cumbersome. You click on the Bluetooth icon on the 2nd page of the menus. The audio quality was somewhat less than the speaker and microphone on the phone itself.KeyboardI am very interested to learn whether a BlueTooth keyboard can work with this phone, either with a built-in program like SMS, or with a Java program. Palm makes an affordable one for their PDAs that could potentially transform the Sciphone into a note-taking device for students -- if it's compatible and supported.Use as modemIt has been revealed in the forums that the phone can be used as a modem for your PC by setting up a BlueTooth connection. Link.CasesThe i68/i68+ are nearly the same size as the 1st-generation iPhoneTM, but not quite.
This is the case that I bought for my i68+ on Amazon. It fits perfectly, it's real leather if the ad is to be believed, and it was cheap. Firmware updatesFor a while firmware updates were available from Javquisoft but they seem to be having financial problems. They provide a program for flashing the phone called Dora.In early 2009, Javquisoft began releasing version 4 of their firmware, which permits them to release improvements to the applications on the phone. It also lets users apply their own look-and-feel customizations to their phone's user interface. The Javquisoft firmware kit may still be available from Zydaglo or MySciphoneShop. Built-in programsCalculatorThis is a very basic calculator without even a square-root button. The Chinese may not realize it, but this could be viewed as a major deficiency by engineers and students.CalendarThe calendar displays a calendar (useful) and lets you enter events for specific dates (clunky and hard to use). However it is worth pointing out that the Apple iPhoneTM's calendar feature is not much better.Currency converterWith the US dollar rapidly becoming worthless thanks to our wonderful leaders, I have little need for this feature.StopwatchThere is a built-in stopwatch program but the time display uses the basic font, which is too small.FM radioIf you're in a city you may get good reception with the radio. If you're any distance from a city however reception will be poor.Missing featuresHere are some features that might be nice but the phone does not have:
HardwareThe processor in the phone is the Mediatek MT6225 and it is running the Nucleus Plus operating system. As of mid-2008 Mediatek appeared to be working on a port of Linux to their processors.Engineering ModeYou can switch to Engineering Mode by dialing *#3646633#. It lets you change a few features. However many of the settings have no effect when changed.Whatever you do, never select "high speed SIM" as this will render the phone nonfunctional i.e. "bricked". Controlling via PCAs webcam via USBThe phone can serve as a webcam for Windows if you download the proper driver. The performance however is rather poor.To update the phone book via USBIt has been reported to me that Wammu (for Windows and Linux) works with this phone, but I have not tried it. You have to set the phone to COM mode, connect to a Windows or Linux PC via USB, and then some phone data can be altered.Javquisoft version 4 firmwareI received my version 4 firmware in May 2009. It downloaded quickly. I ran the installation program Dora, which took about an hour to first back up the old firmware (3.1.2) and then install the new (4.0.0)
Version 4 has the same appearance as version 3, except that it allows
for improvements to the major built-in programs (which subscribers will
receive) and it permits the user to customize the phone applications using the
Key concept: a skin
Installing a skinYou can either obtain a skin by downloading one (yes, I will put one together and post it soonish) or by constructing your own, which I explain about below.
But first, create a directory on your MicroSD drive called
javquisoft (all lower case)
if you haven't already. It is into that directory that you copy
Then you click on the "safely remove hardware" icon under Windows, disconnect the USB, then slide-to-unlock the phone, go to the third menu page and run the Installer. What is the format of package.txt?It's not complicated. You basically just set your wallpaper images usingpackage.txt.
Here is my file that sets up eight of them:
<red blood cells G001= RBC.jpg> <e coli G002= EColi.jpg> <white blood cells G003= Cells.jpg> <muscle G004= muscle.jpg> <mitosis G005= mitosis.jpg> <neuron G006= neuron.JPG> <marbles G007= Marbles2.jpg> <model G008= Face.jpg>Note! You must have a space after the equals sign (=).
If you want to change sounds, you have to copy MP3 files into your
As you can see, version 4 fixes the problem of not being
able to assign an MP3 to the incoming SMS sound.
Note, you cannot use WAV files in the
Note! There is a 2.5 megabyte limit on all of the
sound and image files in your
Here is a list of the files in my
G:> dir javquisoft Volume in drive G has no label. Volume Serial Number is xxxx-xxxx Directory of G:\javquisoft 05/14/2009 05:48 PM 28,040 Cells.jpg 05/14/2009 05:46 PM 34,661 EColi.jpg 05/09/2009 06:19 PM 29,544 Face.jpeg 05/14/2009 05:49 PM 13,772 Marbles2.jpg 05/14/2009 06:13 PM 18,807 mitosis.jpg 05/14/2009 06:07 PM 65,068 muscle.jpg 05/14/2009 06:21 PM 43,261 neuron.JPG 05/14/2009 07:36 PM 622 package.txt 05/14/2009 05:46 PM 49,123 RBC.jpg 05/14/2009 07:49 PM 221,614 RT01.mp3 05/14/2009 07:57 PM 196,999 RT02.mp3 05/14/2009 07:51 PM 45,558 SMS1.mp3 05/14/2009 08:41 PM 1,356 SMS2.mp3 05/14/2009 08:40 PM 12,096 SMS3.mp3 05/14/2009 08:41 PM 1,356 SMS4.mp3 05/14/2009 08:09 PM 45,558 SYS1.mp3 05/14/2009 08:41 PM 1,356 SYS3.mp3 For some ideas on where to get ringtones and other sounds, visit my ringtones page. ConclusionsValue for moneyThe i68+ generally runs for less than $110 as of July 2009. The i68 is less still. These prices appear to be in response to the newer i9b and i9-3g, both of which are rounded-back clone phones. In a few months no doubt prices will have dropped a bit more.As of this writing, given the wealth of features that the i68+ with 3.0a or better firmware provides, it's still a good deal. OverallThe phone has many benefits that are listed in the review above. The phone's main deficiencies in my view are:
Links
|
|