Rosalie Sommer at piano - Copyright; 1999 Rosalie

  Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music, piano, clarinet, flute lessons, located in York County, Pennsylvania, teaching 25 years, all ages, B.A. Music, B.S. Education
teaching 34 years, all ages - B.A. Music, B.S. Education

main page

 site map  to menu at bottom


 Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

links to glossary
shown in side bar

To keep your place after checking a definition, click the return following the defined word in the glossary.

Help on Musical Skills for Children to Begin Composition


Creating a song results in the need for students to examine the music they play in order to discover how it was created. The child sees the need to understand key signatures, tonic, dominant, phrases, meter, the form of simple songs (for example ABA) and more. Children also play their instruments more freely as they learn more about music.

The suggestions are intended to help young students to acquire some basic skills that are needed to experience greater success in creating their own songs. If you are a music student who has some level of advancement and a basic understanding of musical form, key, meter etc., use the listing of musical devices in the Musical Analysis Check List to remind you of things you might try. More advanced students should also consider the musical factors listed in Criteria for an Effective Composition.

Help is given on this page to learn basic principles of a musical phrase for students who have not already acquired these skills as a part of regular music lessons. Help on learning more about meter, form and tonality can be found at Composition Meter, Form & Tonality.

 

 

key signature

meter

duple meter

triple meter


Very Basic Skills Needed

Very basic things a child needs to understand to make a song are:

  • the understanding of key signatures; knowing the scale system a song is based on
  • meter, the rhythmic movement of 2’s or 3’s in a simple song
  • musical phrases

These are skills that even the very youngest child should be learning as a regular part of music lessons. A student should know the key signature of the songs that he is playing for his lessons and be able to play the scale his solo is based on; know whether the song moves in 2’s (duple meter) or 3’s (triple meter); and be able to identify where the phrases are. The following suggestions assume that the student understands these very basic principles.

return to top

 

to menu at bottom

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Side Logo

 

phrase

 

question-answer phrase

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1K

MIDI file


Play the Musical Question-Answer Game With Your Child
A musical question is a phrase that does not make a complete unit. If you stopped at the end of the phrase, it leaves you feeling unsatisfied. It feels and sounds like there is more, the music wants to go on to another phrase. The song does not feel like it could possibly stop there. The musical answer phrase makes the question phrase sound complete. The song might not end there, but if you stopped there it sounds like it could end there.


Discover Musical Question-Answer Phrases

If a child is unable to create simple musical answers to a musical question that you have created, he is probably not ready to create a song. Make a game of working on this skill over a period of time and try again later after the child has more musical experience. Before a child can make his own musical questions and answers, he needs to be able to hear and identify them in songs. Point out the musical questions in songs the child knows. A good song that works well for this is the folk song, Mary Ann.

Mary Ann

Mary Ann folk song 1st phrasefolk song Mary Ann 2nd phrasefolk song Mary Ann 3rd phrasefolk song Mary Ann 4th phrase

Play the MIDI file of Mary Ann 1K (entire song)

If you can play Mary Ann on the piano, it would be helpful to review the song with the child. Play the entire song and play each phrase separately. There are four phrases in Mary Ann. The first three ask a musical question and the fourth answers the musical question.

 

major

 
1. Have the child tell you what key the folk song is in.
It’s in C major.

2. Have the child play a C major scale.

 

C Major Scale
Play the MIDI file, 1K, of the C major scale.

tonic

step

scale

key

Point out to the student that C is tonic, the first scale step or the “home base pitch” and that the melody of Mary Ann uses only the first five scale steps of the C major scale. Explain to the child that tonic scale step, or the first scale step, is represented by a Roman Numeral I. Do is the syllable used for the first scale step and songs want to return home to the tonic scale step, the first scale step, or to do to sound complete. It is critical that the student understands key signatures and that the key identifies the scale a song is based on tells you what pitch material is used in a song. It identifies resting tones, leading tones etc. in a song.

3. Play the entire song of Mary Ann again for the child and then play just the first phrase of Mary Ann, “All day, all night, Mary Ann.” If the child can play the piano, have him play the song.

 Play the MIDI file, 1K, Mary Ann (entire song) again.

 Play the MIDI file, 1K, phrase 1 only of Mary Ann
shown below.

 Phrase 1 Mary Ann

 

phrase 1

Ask the child whether the first phrase sounds like the song could stop there.
Is it a musical question or is it an answer?


The child may know from your previous explanation and his previous experiences that it is a question. If not, explain again that the song does not sound like it could end here on this first phrase so it is a musical question. It sounds like the song has to go on. It does not sound finished. Get the child to understand through listening that the first phrase of Mary Ann does not sound complete. Also get the child to understand intellectually that it does not sound finished or complete because the song, based on the C major scale, does not go home to the first scale step or do. The first phrase ends on the fourth scale step.

4. Play phrases one and two.

 MIDI file, 1K, phrase 1 and 2, Mary Ann

 phrase 1, folk song Mary Ann

 

phrase 1

 phrase 2, folk song Mary Ann

 

phrase 2


sequential

 Does this sound like another question like the first phrase or does it answer it?
Explain to the student that it asks the same question at another pitch level. It is the same melodic material, one scale step lower. It is a “sequential repetition” of the first question.

5. Play the first three phrases.

 MIDI file, 1K, phrase 1, 2 and 3, Mary Ann

 phrase 1, folk song Mary Ann

 

phrase 1

 phrase 2, folk song Mary Ann phrase 2
 phrase 3, folk song Mary Ann

 

phrase 3

Ask the student what this phrase sounds like. Is it a question or an answer phrase? Has he heard this before? The child will probably tell you that it is the same as the first phrase. Point out that the song is asking the same musical question again.

It is not an answer because the song does not sound finished or complete. This phrase is restating the first question exactly as before.

6. Play all four phrases.

MIDI 1K, all 4 phrases, Mary Ann

 phrase 1, folk song Mary Ann

 phrase 2, folk song Mary Ann

 phrase 3, folk song Mary Ann

 phrase 4, folk song Mary Ann

Does this sound answered? Could the song stop here?
Yes, this sounds like the answer. Explain to the student that the fourth phrase is like the second phrase, but instead of ending on the third scale step as the second phrase does it goes to the tonic scale step, “home base pitch” of C since the song is in the key of C major. That’s why it sounds complete.

to site map

Identifying Question-Answer Phrases

Making Question-Answer Phrases

Musical Phrase Form ABA

Form of Song ABA

Meter 2’s, 3’s

Tonality-major, minor, pentatonic

return to top

 

to menu at bottom

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music Logo


Identify Question-Answer Phrases in Skip To My Lou

Another folk song that works well to demonstrate the question-answer phrase idea is Skip to My Lou. In Skip to My Lou there are four phrases. Each phrase of this well-known folk song begins on the word skip. The first three musical phrases ask a musical question three times. The last phrase, “Skip to my lou, my darling,” is the answer.

 Listen for them in the MIDI file, 1K, Skip to My Lou


The Child Learns to Identify the Musical-Answer
Question-Answer Game, Child Makes Answer to Your Made-Up Musical Question
Child Echoes Your Question Phrase, Then Makes Answer

After the child understands simple question-answer phrases in a folk song such as Mary Ann, play a musical question-answer game with the child. Ask the child to create an answer to a musical question that you have created.

Tell the child you are going to make up a musical question and it will be shorter than the musical question in Mary Ann. You will limit your musical question to the first five scale steps in the C major scale.

C Major, first five scale steps
Play the MIDI file, 1K, C, D, E, F, G to listen for the sound of C, the first scale step or do.

C_5NOTES.MID

 

You are going to begin your question on the first scale step, tonic scale step. Many children understand that do re mi fa sol la ti and do are syllables used to represent scale steps. The terms do, tonic, “home base pitch” all represent the first scale step. In the the examples, based on a C major scale, it is C.

Tell the child you are going to make it sound like a question by moving from the first scale step and on any other scale step that is not tonic. You are going to use only quarter, and whole notes in your two measure pattern to keep the first example easy.

 Play the MIDI file, 1K, the musical question shown below.

Q1.MID

 musical question 1

Have the child first echo the phrase you made; then make his own musical answer.

Tell the child that your phrase did not stop on the first scale step in your question so that it would sound like the question. Tell them to echo your question and then make an answer using the same rhythm pattern you used.

Some possible answers are:

 a possible musical answer to musical question 1

MIDI file, 1K, a possible musical answer to question 1

play the MIDI, 1K, file of both the question and answer

 or

 another possible musical answer to musical question 1

 MIDI file, 1K, another possible answer to musical question 1

play the MIDI file, 1K, file of both the question and answer


IT MAY COME EASILY

If the child has already acquired a sense of melodic direction and has tonal skills from his previous musical experiences, it may come easily for the child and will require no further explanation at all. You and the child can have fun making each one more interesting both rhythmically and melodically until you can see where the child begins to need help.


return to top

 

to menu at bottom

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music, piano, clarinet, flute and saxophone lessons


If the Child Cannot Echo Your Simple Phrase, STOP HERE, and Work on That

If the child is unable to echo your very short, simple pattern, you have discovered why he probably had trouble hearing question-answer phrases when you played the folk song, Mary Ann. This skill needs to be acquired before he can make a song. It is also important to the child’s general musical development. Be sure you have limited your examples to short phrases with only intervals of 2nds and 3rds to keep it easy in the beginning. For example; a very simple example using only 2nds and changing direction would be the example below using C D E D E.

 

 musical question 2

MIDI file, 1K, musical question 2

 A possible answer might be:

a possible answer to musical question 2 

MIDI 1K, a possible answer to musical question 2 

 play the MIDI, 1K, file of both the question and answer

 


Concentrate on Direction of Simple Pattern, If Needed

Most children who can play at a beginning level can echo a simple pattern and make a related short answer. If they can’t, work with them on hearing simply whether the music moves up or down. It can be learned. Sometimes having had more musical experiences through listening to music allows the skill to appear. Sometimes children are just listening to pleasing sounds and are not experiencing specific elements of music. When they are encouraged to listen to something specific, they are able to hear it.

return to top

 

 to menu at bottom

Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music, piano, clarinet, flute and saxophone lessons


Question-Answer Game, Child Makes Two Musical Questions and An Answer

If he has easily echoed your musical question and then made a satisfactory answer, get the child to play your musical question-answer phrase again and add a second musical question followed by an answer.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

rhythm

 

 

 

tonality

 Different Keys

When the child succeeds at making musical questions and answers using the limited scale steps of the first five tones of C major, try other keys such as G major.
1. Get him to answer your musical question using another scale such as G major, D major etc.
2. Have him make his own question and then an answer in the new key.
3. Get the child to make a question, another question and then another answer. Keep the melodic material limited to the first five scale steps of G major, G A B C D, until the child can make interesting patterns.


More Varied Rhythm Pattern

The rhythm patterns of the first examples were very short and only quarter note patterns. Try more varied rhythm patterns and make improvisational rhythm patterns that can be answered in imitation or a variation that “sounds” answered. Use the same number of beats in the rhythmic answer as used in the question.
Full Range of Melodic Material

When the child can securely make interesting question answer phrases using limited scale tones, try using the full range of the scale. Remind him to establish the tonality of a specific key and to stay in it for these examples.

 ABA

 Musical Phrase Form ABA
Phrases are arranged in groups. One very common phrase organization is ABA. A folk song that children know that uses this phrase arrangement is Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. It uses A B B A. The letter A represents the first musical idea. B is a different idea. Listen to the whole song, the A section, and then the B section. All of these files are only 1K and will download quickly.

 MIDI file, 1K,
Twinkle Twinkle Little Star (whole)

 MIDI file, 1K,
only the A phrase

 MIDI file, 1K,
only the B phrase



If you need music paper, print some manuscript pages from here. Click on “Back” at the top of your browser to return to this page. There is no other return from the manuscript page.

 

staff paper 1 staff

 

staff paper 2 staffs

Identifying Question-Answer Phrases

Making Question-Answer Phrases

Musical Phrase Form ABA

Form of Song ABA

Meter 2’s, 3’s

Tonality-major, minor, pentatonic

to site map

return to top

brown horizontal bar Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music
Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music, piano, clarinet, flute and saxophone lessons

  Site Map 
 Main Pages   Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music
clarinet
flute

lessons
piano
saxophone

be a composer
Composition
Help for Students
  page 1 be a composer
page 2 song writing for children
page 3 question-answer phrases
page 4 meter, form & tonality

page 5 help for students with good basic skills
page 6
musical analysis check list
page 7
computer use for composition

music staff paper 1 staff
music staff paper 2 staffs
rhymes & poems with strong meter
glossary of musical terms used
Rosalie Sommer
Studio of Music
Studio Information
 

studio schedule
snow days
make up lessons
where located
copyright

Music Lessons
When to Begin
  when to begin piano
when to begin woodwinds
beginning early - piano
later beginning - piano
piano as early beginning for woodwinds
enriching early musical experiences
adult students
Music Lessons
Performance Help
  music links
musical analysis check list
understanding musical form
understanding question-answer phrases
 Fun Page   simple diversions

brown bar Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music

adult piano lessons, all ages clarinet, saxophone, piano, flute

E mail Rosalie Sommer
clarinet lessons, flute lessons, piano lessons, saxophone lessons at Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music York County, PA near Red Lion music lessons
Rosalie Sommer, music teacher, teaches all ages. Music lessons include piano lessons, flute lessons, clarinet lessons and saxophone lessons. The Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music is located in York County, PA serving students in the communities of Airville, Brogue, Craley, Dallastown, Delta, East Prospect, Fawn Grove, Felton, Glen Rock, Hellam, Jacobus, Loganville, New Park, New Freedom, Red Lion, Shrewsbury, Stewartstown, Windsor, Wrightsville, Yoe, and York.
Copyright © 1999-2007 Rosalie Sommer Studio of Music
3920 Brownton Road, Felton, Pennsylvania 17322-7720
Phone: (717) 244-1039
E-mail: rosaliesommer@comcast.net
URL: http://home.comcast.net/~rosaliesommer/
Site created by Rosalie sommer February 16, 1999
Web page created May 30, 1999
Updated September 20, 2007