Give us free!
Basically, to buy wine I have to deal with the state-run distributors who, as a monopoly, are not necessarily inclined to provide either competitive pricing or service or selection. Wineries located out of state cannot ship wine to me directly, though in-state wineries can - an incosistency that has recently been designated as unconstituational by the Supreme Court.
Of course, one way to eilminate this incosistency is to prevent in-state wineries from shipping to consumers - a tactic that essentially screws the small guy wineries and is actually being employed in those offending states that are not simply ignoring the ruling for the time being.
Why do this? Because large distributors have powerful lobbyists and lots of money. And lots to lose - not to me, purchaser of a few direct cases of Opus One or Far Niente for example, but from the big boys: WalMart, Target, CostCo... Those folks could quickly eat up their monopoly wine distribution businesses because they are probably vastly superior at distribution, having to contend competition which the state-run monopolies considered such a nuisance that they did away with it entirely.
I was interrested in where PA stood on all of this, so I wrote my PA state representatives (yes, I'm *that* kind of nerd). It's easy - you can do it yourself in less than 5 minutes with a pre-drafted letter via www.freethegrapes.com.
Anyway, one of my state reps., Curt Schroder, has actually replied, and I'm pleased to report it's in favor of getting wine distributed to the masses in a manner consitent with healthy capitalism. Check out his reply below:
"Dear Mr. Roberts:
Thank you for your recent correspondence concerning the current restrictive laws against the direct shipment of wine purchased from out-of-state wineries. One issue that has historically generated much interest among alcoholic beverage consumers around the state is the Commonwealth's prohibition against residents having wine shipped to their homes from out-of-state sources. Obviously, as it is with you, this restriction has long been a sore spot for many Pennsylvania residents. However, I assure you that I agree with frustrated consumers who have longed for the ability to purchase wines of their choice, in the manner of their own choosing. I believe consumers should be given the ability to decide which wines they want and from where they wish to make the purchase.
Furthermore, I agree with your assessment that interstate direct shipments of wine would encourage fair and open trade within the Commonwealth. It is both convenient and cost efficient for many consumers to purchase alcohol this way and it is difficult to enforce the law that prohibits these transactions. That being said. I would like to point out that i am a cosponsor of House Bill 624, the wine industry's model direct shipping bill, which was introduced by Representative Godshall. The bill currently awaits consideration in the House Liquor Control Committee.
Again, I thank you for taking the time to contact me regarding your concerns and I invite you to contact me again if I can provide you with any further information or updates on this issue.
Very truly yours,
CURT SCHRODER,
Member 155th Legislative District"


