| Year | Best New Product | Best Magazine Issue | Best Article | Best New Scenario | Best Reprint Scenario | Best ASL Website |
| 2001 | ASL Rulebook v2 Multi-Man Publishing |
ASL Journal #3 Multi-Man Publishing |
B9.5 Bocage Ian Daglish ASL Journal #3 |
J63 - Silesian Interlude ASL Journal #3 |
J43 - 3rd RTR in the Rain ASL Journal #3 |
Coastal Fortress Scott Faulk and Steve Svare |
| 2000 | ASL Journal #2 Multi-Man Publishing |
Dispatches From The Bunker #10 The Bunker Crew |
A Comprehensive Rout Example Tom Repetti ASL Journal #2 |
J32 - Panzer Graveyard ASL Journal #2 |
J19 - Merzenhausen Zoo ASL Journal #2 |
Coastal Fortress Scott Faulk and Steve Svare |
| 1999 | Blood Reef: Tarawa Multi-Man Publishing |
ASL Journal #1 Multi-Man Publishing |
Overrun Flowchart Tom Repetti, JR van Mechelen, and Perry Cocke Action Pack #2 |
J1 - Urban Guerillas ASL Journal #1 |
J8 - Block Busting in Bokruisk ASL Journal #1 |
Multi-Man Publishing |
| 1998 | Doomed Battalions Avalon Hill and Multi-Man Publishing |
- | *TIE* Doing The Wave ASL Crossfire: KGP7 The Bridge at Cheneux |
84 - Round One Doomed Battalions |
E - Hill 621 Classic ASL Pack |
ASL Crossroads Jacques Cuneo |
| 1997 | 1997 ASL Annual Multi-Man Publishing |
- |
Vive La France Encore! Mark Nixon 1997 ASL Annual |
TOT45 - The Dogs of War Time on Target #3 |
KE5 - Beyond the Pakfronts March Madness '97 scenario pack |
ASL Crossroads Jacques Cuneo |
| 1996 | - | 1996 ASL Annual Multi-Man Publishing |
OBA Flowchart Brian Sielski, Robert Banozic, Perry Cocke, Mark Simonitch, and Louie Tokarz Action Pack 1 |
Platoon Leader G - Cemetery Hill Critical Hit |
U - Chance D'une Affaire | ASL Crossroads Jacques Cuneo |
| 1995 | - | Backblast #2 Multi-Man Publishing |
Dance With the Tiger JR VanMechelen Backblast #2 |
TOT 7 - Tiger 222 Time on Target #1 * |
A68 - Acts of Defiance ASL Annual 95 * |
Tim Hundsdorfer |
* - New and Reprint scenarios were not separate categories for 1995, but had they been, these would have been the results. Acts of Defiance won the "Best Scenario" category that year, and Tiger 222 was in second place.